Java garbage collector - When does it collect?

Question

What is it that determines when the garbage collector actually collects? Does it happen after a certain time or after a certain amount of memory have been used up? Or are there other factors?

Answer 1

It runs when it determines that it is time to run. A common strategy in generational garbage collectors is to run the collector when an allocation of generation-0 memory fails. That is, every time you allocate a small block of memory (big blocks are typically placed directly into "older" generations), the system checks whether there's enough free space in the gen-0 heap, and if there isn't, it runs the GC to free up space for the allocation to succeed. Old data is then moved to the gen-1 heap, and when space runs out there, the GC runs a collection on that, upgrading the data which has been there longest to the gen-2 heap, and so on. So the GC doesn't just "run". It might run on the gen-0 heap only (and most collections will do just that), or it might check every generation if it really has to free up a lot of memory (which is only necessary fairly rarely).

But this is far from the only strategy. A concurrent GC runs in the background, cleaning up while the program is running. Some GC's might run as part of every memory allocation. An incremental collector might do that, scanning a few objects at every memory allocation.

The entire point in a garbage collector is that it should just do its thing without requiring any input from the user. So in general, you can't, and shouldn't, predict when it'll run.

I believe Suns JVM gained a generational GC not too long ago (v1.6 maybe? I haven't coded Java for ages, so not sure on this, but I remember being surprised not too long ago, when one of the selling points for the new version was "a generational GC". Not least because .NET has had one since day 1.)

Other JVM's are of course free to pick whichever strategy they like.

EDIT: The above part about Java and generational GC is not true. See below for more details:

The 1.0 and 1.1 Virtual Machines used a mark-sweep collector, which could fragment the heap after a garbage collection. Starting with Java 1.2, the Virtual Machines switched to a generational collector, which has a much better defragmentation behavior (see Java theory and practice: Garbage collection and performance).

So Java actually has a generational GC for ages. What's new in Java 6 is the Garbage-First garbage collector (G1) that is available in Java 6u14. According to the article claiming the release in 1.6.0_14: It is not enabled by default. The parallel collector is still the default GC and is the most efficient GC for common household usage. G1 is meant to be an alternative for the concurrent collector. It is designed to be more predictable and enable fast allocation with memory regions design.

Answer 2

• It depends on way program JIT compiled.
• From outside we cannot definitely tell when it will run.
• It follows some algorithm which depends on that particular GC.
• Java virtual machine runs on the client machine with some virtual memory in case of windows default is 4GB. It also depends on that free virtual memory at that particular time.

You can try this small program to check behavior of GC

public class GCTest {

   final int NELEMS = 50000;

   void eatMemory() {

      int[] intArray = new int[NELEMS];

      for (int i=0; i<NELEMS; i++) {
        intArray[i] = i;
      }

   }

   public static void main (String[] args) {

      GCTest gct = new GCTest();

      // Step 1: get a Runtime object
      Runtime r = Runtime.getRuntime();

      // Step 2: determine the current amount of free memory
      long freeMem = r.freeMemory();
      System.out.println("free memory before creating array: " + freeMem);

      // Step 3: consume some memory
      gct.eatMemory();

      // Step 4: determine amount of memory left after consumption
      freeMem = r.freeMemory();
      System.out.println("free memory after creating array:  " + freeMem);

      // Step 5: run the garbage collector, then check freeMemory
      r.gc();
      freeMem = r.freeMemory();
      System.out.println("free memory after running gc():    " + freeMem);
   }
}

possible output -- May be different in your case

free memory before creating array: 4054912
free memory after creating array:  3852496
free memory after running gc():    4064184

Check this link http://www.devdaily.com/java/edu/pj/pj010008/

Answer 3

When the JVM doesn't have necessary memory space to run, the garbage collector will run and delete unnecessary objects to free up memory.

Unnecessary objects are the objects which have no other references (address) pointing to them.

There are mainly 4 ways an object can eligible for garbage collection.

1. Null Referencing

   The garbage collector can delete an object when the reference variable of the object is assigned null as its value.

       A a = new A();
       a = null;
   

2. Re-assigning

   When another object is assigned to the reference variable of an object, the older referenced object can be deleted by the garbage collector.

     A a = new A(100);
     a =new A(200);
   

3. Local Scope

   If an object is created inside a block, then that object will be eligible for garbage collection outside that block.

     if(condition){
   
        A a = new A();
   
     }
   

4. Isolation

   An object can contain a reference to another object, but there must be at least one reference (address) variable for those objects in the stack, otherwise all those objects are eligible for garbage collection.

         class A{
               A r;
               A(int i){
                //something   
              }
         } 
   
         A a1 = new A(100);
         a1.r = new A(101);
         a1.r.r = new A(102);
         a1.r.r.r = a1;
   
         a1  = null //all ojects are eligible to garbage collector  
   

Answer 4

It depends a lot on what garbage collector you're actually using, how its tuned, and a whole lot of inputs.

For a run down of the HotSpot Garbage Collector (the common one that comes with Java) and how it's tuned, you can check out this link

Answer 5

This completely depends on the actual JVM and what it chooses to do, and is basically out of your hands as a programmer. Greybearded die-hard experts may want to tell the JVM they know better, but for mere mortals this should be considered black magic better left alone.

What should concern you is if it can keep up with the rate that your programs creates and discards objects. If not your whole program is halted while global cleaning up occurs. That turns out to very bad response times, but happens rarely for modern JVM's on modern computers.

If you are curious about what happens in your program and when, then investigate the "jvisualvm" tool in the recent versions of the Java 6 JDK. It is really great for peeking inside.

Answer 6

The garbage collector runs when it needs resources and on a regular basis that you able to influence by telling when is a good time to spend CPU on collecting, using System.gc()

You can help the garbage collector by nulling references explicitly, for instance by giving your objects init() methods that allocate resources and cleanup() methods that explicitly clean up those resources and nulling their references. By nulling references yourself you prevent tye garbage collector from having to find clusters of obects that have to more paths to a root.