12

Documentation says that waypoints limit is 8 points. But I have to find best waypoints order list from more than 50 waypoints. How to do that?

I am able to find waypoints order by using Start + Destination + 8 Waypoints But I need help for more than 50 Waypoints

Raviranjan Mishra
  • 849
  • 2
  • 11
  • 26
  • Currently, in 2016, the documentation says that maximum number of waypoints in Directions API web service is 23. – xomena Oct 30 '16 at 12:01

5 Answers5

16

function initMap() {
    var service = new google.maps.DirectionsService;
    var map = new google.maps.Map(document.getElementById('map'));

    // list of points
    var stations = [
        {lat: 48.9812840, lng: 21.2171920, name: 'Station 1'},
        {lat: 48.9832841, lng: 21.2176398, name: 'Station 2'},
        {lat: 48.9856443, lng: 21.2209088, name: 'Station 3'},
        {lat: 48.9861461, lng: 21.2261563, name: 'Station 4'},
        {lat: 48.9874682, lng: 21.2294855, name: 'Station 5'},
        {lat: 48.9909244, lng: 21.2295512, name: 'Station 6'},
        {lat: 48.9928871, lng: 21.2292352, name: 'Station 7'},
        {lat: 48.9921334, lng: 21.2246742, name: 'Station 8'},
        {lat: 48.9943196, lng: 21.2234792, name: 'Station 9'},
        {lat: 48.9966345, lng: 21.2221262, name: 'Station 10'},
        {lat: 48.9981191, lng: 21.2271386, name: 'Station 11'},
        {lat: 49.0009168, lng: 21.2359527, name: 'Station 12'},
        {lat: 49.0017950, lng: 21.2392890, name: 'Station 13'},
        {lat: 48.9991912, lng: 21.2398272, name: 'Station 14'},
        {lat: 48.9959850, lng: 21.2418410, name: 'Station 15'},
        {lat: 48.9931772, lng: 21.2453901, name: 'Station 16'},
        {lat: 48.9963512, lng: 21.2525850, name: 'Station 17'},
        {lat: 48.9985134, lng: 21.2508423, name: 'Station 18'},
        {lat: 49.0085000, lng: 21.2508000, name: 'Station 19'},
        {lat: 49.0093000, lng: 21.2528000, name: 'Station 20'},
        {lat: 49.0103000, lng: 21.2560000, name: 'Station 21'},
        {lat: 49.0112000, lng: 21.2590000, name: 'Station 22'},
        {lat: 49.0124000, lng: 21.2620000, name: 'Station 23'},
        {lat: 49.0135000, lng: 21.2650000, name: 'Station 24'},
        {lat: 49.0149000, lng: 21.2680000, name: 'Station 25'},
        {lat: 49.0171000, lng: 21.2710000, name: 'Station 26'},
        {lat: 49.0198000, lng: 21.2740000, name: 'Station 27'},
        {lat: 49.0305000, lng: 21.3000000, name: 'Station 28'},
    ];
    
    // Zoom and center map automatically by stations (each station will be in visible map area)
    var lngs = stations.map(function(station) { return station.lng; });
    var lats = stations.map(function(station) { return station.lat; });
    map.fitBounds({
        west: Math.min.apply(null, lngs),
        east: Math.max.apply(null, lngs),
        north: Math.min.apply(null, lats),
        south: Math.max.apply(null, lats),
    });
    
    // Show stations on the map as markers
    for (var i = 0; i < stations.length; i++) {
        if (!stations[i].name)
            continue;
        new google.maps.Marker({
            position: stations[i],
            map: map,
            title: stations[i].name
        });
    }

    // Divide route to several parts because max stations limit is 25 (23 waypoints + 1 origin + 1 destination)
    for (var i = 0, parts = [], max = 8 - 1; i < stations.length; i = i + max)
        parts.push(stations.slice(i, i + max + 1));

    // Callback function to process service results
    var service_callback = function(response, status) {
        if (status != 'OK') {
            console.log('Directions request failed due to ' + status);
            return;
        }
        var renderer = new google.maps.DirectionsRenderer;
        renderer.setMap(map);
        renderer.setOptions({ suppressMarkers: true, preserveViewport: true });
        renderer.setDirections(response);
    };
        
    // Send requests to service to get route (for stations count <= 25 only one request will be sent)
    for (var i = 0; i < parts.length; i++) {
        // Waypoints does not include first station (origin) and last station (destination)
        var waypoints = [];
        for (var j = 1; j < parts[i].length - 1; j++)
            waypoints.push({location: parts[i][j], stopover: false});
        // Service options
        var service_options = {
            origin: parts[i][0],
            destination: parts[i][parts[i].length - 1],
            waypoints: waypoints,
            travelMode: 'WALKING'
        };
        // Send request
        service.route(service_options, service_callback);
    }
  }
html, body {
    height: 100%;
    margin: 0;
    padding: 0;
}
#map {
    height: 100%;     
    width: 100%;
    height: 100%;
}
<div id="map"></div>

<!-- without API KEY set variable "max" to 8 -->
<script async defer src="https://maps.googleapis.com/maps/api/js?callback=initMap"></script>

<!-- with API KEY set variable "max" to 25 -->
<!-- <script async defer src="https://maps.googleapis.com/maps/api/js?callback=initMap&key=YOUR_API_KEY"></script>-->

With following code you can use as many waypoints as you need and you will never get error MAX_WAYPOINTS_EXCEEDED. Do not forget to replace "YOUR_API_KEY" to your API KEY or remove &key=YOUR_API_KEY from google API URL and set variable "max" to 8 (max = 25 when using API KEY, max = 8 when not using API KEY).

<div id="map"></div>
<script>
  function initMap() {
    var service = new google.maps.DirectionsService;
    var map = new google.maps.Map(document.getElementById('map'));

    // list of points
    var stations = [
        {lat: 48.9812840, lng: 21.2171920, name: 'Station 1'},
        {lat: 48.9832841, lng: 21.2176398, name: 'Station 2'},
        {lat: 48.9856443, lng: 21.2209088, name: 'Station 3'},
        {lat: 48.9861461, lng: 21.2261563, name: 'Station 4'},
        {lat: 48.9874682, lng: 21.2294855, name: 'Station 5'},
        {lat: 48.9909244, lng: 21.2295512, name: 'Station 6'},
        {lat: 48.9928871, lng: 21.2292352, name: 'Station 7'},
        {lat: 48.9921334, lng: 21.2246742, name: 'Station 8'},
        {lat: 48.9943196, lng: 21.2234792, name: 'Station 9'},
        {lat: 48.9966345, lng: 21.2221262, name: 'Station 10'},
        {lat: 48.9981191, lng: 21.2271386, name: 'Station 11'},
        {lat: 49.0009168, lng: 21.2359527, name: 'Station 12'},
        {lat: 49.0017950, lng: 21.2392890, name: 'Station 13'},
        {lat: 48.9991912, lng: 21.2398272, name: 'Station 14'},
        {lat: 48.9959850, lng: 21.2418410, name: 'Station 15'},
        {lat: 48.9931772, lng: 21.2453901, name: 'Station 16'},
        {lat: 48.9963512, lng: 21.2525850, name: 'Station 17'},
        {lat: 48.9985134, lng: 21.2508423, name: 'Station 18'},
        {lat: 49.0085000, lng: 21.2508000, name: 'Station 19'},
        {lat: 49.0093000, lng: 21.2528000, name: 'Station 20'},
        {lat: 49.0103000, lng: 21.2560000, name: 'Station 21'},
        {lat: 49.0112000, lng: 21.2590000, name: 'Station 22'},
        {lat: 49.0124000, lng: 21.2620000, name: 'Station 23'},
        {lat: 49.0135000, lng: 21.2650000, name: 'Station 24'},
        {lat: 49.0149000, lng: 21.2680000, name: 'Station 25'},
        {lat: 49.0171000, lng: 21.2710000, name: 'Station 26'},
        {lat: 49.0198000, lng: 21.2740000, name: 'Station 27'},
        {lat: 49.0305000, lng: 21.3000000, name: 'Station 28'},
        // ... as many other stations as you need
    ];

    // Zoom and center map automatically by stations (each station will be in visible map area)
    var lngs = stations.map(function(station) { return station.lng; });
    var lats = stations.map(function(station) { return station.lat; });
    map.fitBounds({
        west: Math.min.apply(null, lngs),
        east: Math.max.apply(null, lngs),
        north: Math.min.apply(null, lats),
        south: Math.max.apply(null, lats),
    });

    // Show stations on the map as markers
    for (var i = 0; i < stations.length; i++) {
        new google.maps.Marker({
            position: stations[i],
            map: map,
            title: stations[i].name
        });
    }

    // Divide route to several parts because max stations limit is 25 (23 waypoints + 1 origin + 1 destination)
    for (var i = 0, parts = [], max = 25 - 1; i < stations.length; i = i + max)
        parts.push(stations.slice(i, i + max + 1));

    // Service callback to process service results
    var service_callback = function(response, status) {
        if (status != 'OK') {
            console.log('Directions request failed due to ' + status);
            return;
        }
        var renderer = new google.maps.DirectionsRenderer;
        renderer.setMap(map);
        renderer.setOptions({ suppressMarkers: true, preserveViewport: true });
        renderer.setDirections(response);
    };

    // Send requests to service to get route (for stations count <= 25 only one request will be sent)
    for (var i = 0; i < parts.length; i++) {
        // Waypoints does not include first station (origin) and last station (destination)
        var waypoints = [];
        for (var j = 1; j < parts[i].length - 1; j++)
            waypoints.push({location: parts[i][j], stopover: false});
        // Service options
        var service_options = {
            origin: parts[i][0],
            destination: parts[i][parts[i].length - 1],
            waypoints: waypoints,
            travelMode: 'WALKING'
        };
        // Send request
        service.route(service_options, service_callback);
    }
  }
</script>
<script async defer src="https://maps.googleapis.com/maps/api/js?key=YOUR_API_KEY&callback=initMap"></script>
mikep
  • 5,880
  • 2
  • 30
  • 37
  • 2
    This doesn't work as you "divide the route to several parts", but those parts are chunks of 25 completely arbitrary points. There's no guarantee that the points you randomly bunched into groups of 25 are even close to eachother. In fact, if you could be sure that `point[i]` was close to `point[i+1]` there wouldn't be a need to optimize the route at all. – Robin De Schepper Mar 04 '20 at 10:46
  • 1
    Points optimization in my case was not needed. Points in my case are known and I just needed to connect it (points are public transport vehicle stations and they usually goes from one to another in row). It depends on purpose. In many cases it is suitable solution but I agree that not for 100% cases. By upvotes in this answer and this https://stackoverflow.com/a/43458012/3826175 including positive comments it helped many users. There is no other better way until google increase limit. – mikep Mar 04 '20 at 11:53
  • The question asks "to find best waypoints order" which this answer won't do. – Robin De Schepper Mar 04 '20 at 18:01
  • I think there could be a solution. In my case points usually goes one to another in row (because of bus stations points are already optimized) so my solution works well. In case points are random you should sort it by distance first - e.g. using haversine algorithm https://stackoverflow.com/a/365853/3826175 or there are easier + faster algorithms usable when all points are in radius several kilometers (can assume that earth is flat). When points are sorted by distance (not random) there is a high probability to get correct result when passing points to my solution which splits route to parts. – mikep Mar 05 '20 at 09:57
  • 1
    Sorting by distance to what? To your reference point? Then you sort them by radius in a sphere/circle around you, after just 1km distance sorting, the points will be 0 to 2 radii (2km) away from eachother depending on the direction they are located at from you. If you sort each point by the distance to the previous closest point then you have an O(n^2) algorithm that does a random walk, better just do a random walk then. The travelling salesman problem cannot be solved like this. It's notorious complexity to solve is exactly why the waypoints are so limited – Robin De Schepper Mar 05 '20 at 12:03
  • Sorry, I don't mean to come down on you hard. It was important to me to point out this won't yield optimized routes. – Robin De Schepper Mar 05 '20 at 12:05
3

I've created a workaround but it is a bit more expensive (in terms of API calls) to use.

Instead of creating a single call with the start, end, and waypoints LatLngs, I split the waypoints into pairs make the calls per pair.

Example:

Problem: Route and get Directions for 100 points

Solution:

  • Call 1: Point 1 and Point 2
  • Call 2: Point 2 and Point 3
  • Call 3: Point 3 and Point 4

    ... and so on.

With this solution you'll never have to worry about the 8 waypoint limitation since you're only making a 2 point query every time. The weakness of this solution is you will be creating a lot of calls and it will eat up your 2500 free calls per day if not used properly.

Ron
  • 1,721
  • 1
  • 19
  • 43
  • Yes, You are right. This process will spend all available free calls limit. In my case there is going to have `19K-20K` points per day. So this solution is not going to help me. – Raviranjan Mishra Mar 17 '15 at 18:30
  • What about optimizing the route? Anything for that? – Adam Azad Aug 05 '16 at 20:54
  • HI, Google usually does its own route optimizations on the fly based on your passed parameters. – Ron Aug 09 '16 at 11:16
1

Ufortunately it is not possible to do.

I'f you have a business account you can add up to around 25 waypoints. A business account is quite expensive.

You need to look for another vendor if you need to use more than 25 waypoints.

JuniorCoder
  • 342
  • 1
  • 17
1

I have found this workaround.

It seems like it does exactly what you need. take a look: http://lemonharpy.wordpress.com/2011/12/15/working-around-8-waypoint-limit-in-google-maps-directions-api/

JuniorCoder
  • 342
  • 1
  • 17
1

HERE Maps (https://developer.here.com/blog/delivery-made-easy-with-the-here-waypoint-sequence-api) offers Waypoints Optimization up to 120 waypoints. Check them out, their prices are very reasonable as well

Chaim Friedman
  • 720
  • 6
  • 24