Detecting function object (functor) and lambda traits

Question

How can I detect the return type and parameter types of nullary and unary function pointers, std::function objects, and functors (including lambdas)?

Boost's function_traits and functional traits don't quite get me there out of the box, but I'm open to supplementing or replacing them.

I could do something like this:

namespace nsDetail
{
    class Dummy { Dummy(); };
}

template<class Fn> struct FnTraits;

template<class R>
struct FnTraits<R(*)()>
{
    typedef nsDetail::Dummy ParamType;
    typedef R               ReturnType;
    typedef R Signature();
};

template<class R, class P>
struct FnTraits<R(*)(P)>
{
    typedef P ParamType;
    typedef R ReturnType;
    typedef R Signature( P );
};

template<class R>
struct FnTraits< std::function<R()> >
{
    typedef nsDetail::Dummy ParamType;
    typedef R               ReturnType;
    typedef R Signature();
};

template<class R, class P>
struct FnTraits< std::function<R(P)> >
{
    typedef P ParamType;
    typedef R ReturnType;
    typedef R Signature( P );
};

But how should I specialize for functors/lambdas?

Update: Perhaps something like in this answer to a different question, but translated from overloading to specialization?

Luc Danton · Accepted Answer · 2011-06-01T14:10:13.987

It's not possible in the general case for functors, i.e. class types using operator(). This includes lambda objects, too. Consider a case where operator() is overloaded:

struct functor {
    double
    operator()(double) const;

    int
    operator()(int) const;
};

typedef function_traits<functor>::result_type result_type;

What should result_type be?

Note that, as a workaround, some protocols (e.g. boost::apply_visitor from Boost.Variant) require that a result_type be present in the class, with the assumption that all overloads, while accepting different types, all return a type compatible with this result_type.

And of course given some types T0 ... Tn, std::result_of<functor(T0, ..., Tn)>::type gives the return type associated to the parameter types.

In the case where exactly one overload of operator() is present[1], you can take the operator() member and inspect that.

struct not_overloaded {
    double
    operator()(double) const;
};

template<typename T>
struct functor_traits {
    typedef decltype(&T::operator()) type;
};

functor_traits<not_overloaded>::type has type double (not_overloaded::*)(double) const here, and with just a bit of effort you can extract from this what you want. (e.g. a specialization of the form Ret (T::*)(Args...) const will match that type.)

[1]: but a functor can provide functionality by implicitly converting to a function pointer/reference, too, so you could miss that

What about something like in this answer: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/4170201/c0x-overloading-on-lambda-arity/4196447#4196447 It's using overloading, but maybe something similar could work for specialization? — metal, Jun 01 '11 at 13:59

score 1 · Answer 2 · answered Jun 01 '11 at 13:51

1

What's wrong with std::result_of?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C%2B%2B0x#Uniform_method_for_computing_the_return_type_of_function_objects

answered Jun 01 '11 at 13:51

sehe

374,641
47
450
633

2

I also need parameter types and the signature. – metal Jun 01 '11 at 13:58

Detecting function object (functor) and lambda traits

2 Answers2

Linked