Secure Handshake failing (SSL)

Question

I'm usng a library called Lacewing. http://lacewing-project.org/

It uses windows crypt api to make a secure server.

I have created a certificate for my PC (Josh-Laptop), and I used netsh to bind it to port 8012. Lacewing says the certificate is successfully loaded.

Then come the problems. I'm trying to send messages from 1 pc in my house (the host) to another (the client).

When I do not load a certificate and use it in unsafe mode, all messages are sent and received.

    void ServerCore::onConnect( Lacewing::Server::Client &client )
    {
        client.SendWritable("test");
    }

...

    void ServerCore::onReceive( 
        Lacewing::Server::Client &client, char * data, int size )
    {
        getServer().FirstClient()->SendWritable("test");
        client.SendWritable("test");
        std::cout << data << " was received from " << client.GetAddress().ToString() << std::endl;
    }

    void ClientCore::onConnect()
    {
        getClient().Send("test");
    }


    void ClientCore::onReceive( char * data, int size )
    {
        getClient().Send("Okay then...");
        std::cout << data << std::endl;
    }

On the client side, I receive 'test'. On the server side, the library spits out an error saying "hand shake failed", "overlapped io operation is in progress"

This is how I load the certificate:

getServer().LoadSystemCertificate("MY","JOSH-LAPTOP","localmachine");

Why would the handshake fail? Is there something I do not understand? Thanks