JSF Action vs Outcome Attribute

Question

I'm new to JSF and am trying to understand what the difference is between the action vs the outcome attributes? This is not the difference between buttons and command buttons, but between outcome vs action attributes on the same button tag.

For instance, I can have:

<h:button value="Go" outcome="<value>" />

or

<h:button value="Go" action="<value>" />

I'm not sure when to use which one. Also, does it make a difference if <value> is <#{bean.methodThatReturnsStringInNavigationRule}> or <string literal in navigation rule>?

Thank you.

Buttons are typically used for navigation, while command buttons are typically used to perform business actions (and, if necessary, navigation). — skuntsel, Feb 23 '13 at 08:09
As per your update, no one JSF component has both attributes in the same tag. The `` doesn't support `action` attribute at all. The `action` attribute is only supported in ``. — BalusC, Feb 26 '13 at 17:54
The title of this question makes it much more easy to find now. I don't think it should be considered duplciate anymore. — bjedrzejewski, Jun 19 '14 at 13:13

Aritz · Accepted Answer · 2013-02-23T00:45:26.427

15

Difference is that while action defines a server method to be executed, outcome specifies a view-id which will be destination of your page. You must use JSF inputs depending on the goal you're trying to achieve:

<h:button outcome="user-management"> targets you to the user management page. Imagine it as kind of link.
<h:commandButton action="#{backingBean.goToUserManagement}" If you return "user-management" in your action method, is doing the same as the outcome but it allows you to execute some logic into the server side. It must be embedded into a h:form tag.

Also there's no difference between <h:button outcome="user-management"> or <h:button outcome="#{backingBean.userManagementNavigationResult}">, as far as your server side getter method returns "user-management" value.

edited Feb 23 '13 at 00:45

answered Feb 23 '13 at 00:40

Aritz

30,971
16
136
217

4

`` can be used outside of a ``, while `` can't. – Luiggi Mendoza Feb 23 '13 at 00:46
Also, **action** does not *necessarily* rely on a bean method, but, of course, if it is not the case then why not use ``. – skuntsel Feb 23 '13 at 08:06
thank you. and what about the permutation of outcome=#{backing-bean}? – dev Feb 26 '13 at 17:45
It just prints the outcome value as string. – BalusC Feb 26 '13 at 17:56
h:button renders as a input type="submit" – Mark W Feb 05 '15 at 10:12

SRy · Answer 2 · 2013-02-23T00:20:54.667

If you see JSF 2.0 API there is no action attribute for <h:button> tag. <h:button> is a new tag in JSF 2.0. You can declared the navigation outcome directly in the outcome attribute, no need to call a bean to return an outcome like <h:commandButton>.

But, if browser’s with JavaScript disabled, the navigation will failed, because the “h:button” tag is generate an “onclick” event to handle the navigation via window.location.href.

<h:button value="buton" outcome="login" />

//HTML output

<input type="button" 
       onclick="window.location.href='/ContextRoot/faces/login.xhtml; return false;" 
       value="buton" />

Source : mkyong. My favorite website where you can find decent examples.

Excellent Blog for JSF : BalusC. A Hero to so many people on this forum:).

JSF Action vs Outcome Attribute

2 Answers2

Linked