Embedded scripting engine for DSL

Question

I'm working on a project which needs an embedded DSL to fullfill its expected requirements.

The DSL would be user defined event based. Here goes a mockup of the desired syntax:

user-defined-event-1 {
    // event body
}

user-defined-event-2 {
    // event body
}

Probably, most similar language I know based on events is LSL (from Second Life).

So, after reading other similar questions on SO, I would like to ask for the best embeddable scripting engine (Ruby, Lua, Python, etc) on C++ (I work in Qt) which allows me to create this DSL.

In my project, I would test that the script properly uses the DSL syntax (at least one event defined) and give the user all the power of the underlying scripting engine and, if possible, Qt.

It is not a requirement for the embedded language to work with Qt. It can be isolated, but it would be nice to have some integration too.

Thanks for your comments, I am going to check unanswered ones as soon as possible, because they need a more deeper look than others. — Dario Castañé, Oct 20 '09 at 22:03
Thanks again to everybody. I choose Lua due its truly embeddable way to work and Qt bindings, although QtScript/V8 were good options too. Python looks too hard to embed for me now. — Dario Castañé, Oct 21 '09 at 17:32

score 3 · Accepted Answer · answered Oct 19 '09 at 21:03

3

There's at least a few Qt-Lua bindings out there. Lua can somewhat do the syntax you've shown above; specifically, {} indicates a table (associative array) in Lua, and if you are only passing an anonymous table to a function, you don't need parentheses:

Lua 5.1.4  Copyright (C) 1994-2008 Lua.org, PUC-Rio
> function LengthOfTable(t) print(#t) end
> LengthOfTable ({"a","b","c"})
3
> LengthOfTable {"a","b","c"}
3

Whether Lua is actually the best for your application, depends on your application, of course. Either way, Lua is very easy (IMO) to embed in C or C++.

answered Oct 19 '09 at 21:03

Mark Rushakoff

249,864
45
407
398

Now I understand why Lua is a popular choice in game scripting. It looks very powerful and, as you said, very easy to embed (this is a wondeful example: http://cc.byexamples.com/20080607/how-to-embed-lua-51-in-c/). Also it works crossplatform and have a familiar syntax (at first glance, similar to Ruby, but I know that it is not) so I am not losing any feature adopting it in my project. Thanks! – Dario Castañé Oct 21 '09 at 17:30

score 1 · Answer 2 · answered Oct 19 '09 at 21:11

1

You could look at embeddable javascript, through Google's V8 project, which is written in C++.

http://code.google.com/apis/v8/intro.html

answered Oct 19 '09 at 21:11

James Black

41,583
10
86
166

That's a good point too but I'm in the same way as QtScript. I guess I can build a DSL on Java/ECMAscript and provide it as a mandatory library. – Dario Castañé Oct 20 '09 at 22:00

score 1 · Answer 3 · answered Oct 19 '09 at 21:22

1

Qt comes with the QtScript scripting module. It uses an ECMAScript based langauge (like javascript).

answered Oct 19 '09 at 21:22

Karl Voigtland

7,637
34
29

Before asking I took a look to QtScript but I did not find a clue to build a DSL upon it. – Dario Castañé Oct 20 '09 at 21:51
If you google 'javascript dsl' you may be able to find some useful information. – Karl Voigtland Oct 20 '09 at 23:22

score 1 · Answer 4 · answered Oct 19 '09 at 23:09

1

Tcl comes fairly close to your proposed syntax:

proc user-defined-event-1 {} {
# event body
puts "Hello World"
}

proc defines a procedure, and the extra {} braces are used for arguments. In a tcl shell, procedures can be dynamically typed in line-by-line, copied and pasted, or loaded from a file. They can also be redefined by simply reloading them.

answered Oct 19 '09 at 23:09

Joe Internet

571
1
3
4

I found out some info about DSL building on TCL, but Lua's looks better. Thanks anyway! – Dario Castañé Oct 21 '09 at 17:31

score 0 · Answer 5 · answered Oct 19 '09 at 21:05

0

I've never tried it but there is PyQt.

answered Oct 19 '09 at 21:05

Troubadour

13,334
2
38
57

Thanks but PyQt is just a binding upon Qt libraries. I need to embed a scripting engine in a C++ project which allows to build a DSL on it and, if possible, have bindings with Qt. Maybe I can embed python and use PyQt inside. – Dario Castañé Oct 20 '09 at 21:57

score 0 · Answer 6 · answered Oct 19 '09 at 21:09

0

I believe boost::python is pretty easy to implement. I hear there are some python-Qt solutions too.

answered Oct 19 '09 at 21:09

Maciek

19,435
18
63
87

score 0 · Answer 7 · answered Oct 19 '09 at 21:17

0

You seem to have very specific requirements for picking a generic DSL. You may want to try a generic DSL library (e.g. Boost.Proto) rather than a prexisting-embedded language.

answered Oct 19 '09 at 21:17

coppro

14,338
5
58
73

Very interesting option but I guess that the created DSL is going to miss any basic feature (conditional flow, for example) provided for a preexisting embedded language unless I implement it on purpose. Am I right? – Dario Castañé Oct 20 '09 at 21:54

Glenn · Answer 8 · 2020-04-12T16:40:57.693

0

For embedding a DSL within your app, I recommend ANTLR. I have used ANTLR over the years, the latest being within a JDBC driver for Cassandra. You might want to try version 4 which has a C++ runtime. Version 3 was problematic with Qt over a collision with the keyword emit.

edited Apr 12 '20 at 16:40

answered May 01 '13 at 07:09

Glenn

7,874
3
29
38

Embedded scripting engine for DSL

8 Answers8

Linked