Need git rebase -Xignore-all-space to preserve my space

Question

I am doing a rebase of a big change, with a lot of whitespace changes. In order for the merge to work at all, I need -Xignore-all-space.

According to git --help rebase:

ignore-space-change, ignore-all-space, ignore-space-at-eol

Treats lines with the indicated type of whitespace change as unchanged for the sake of a three-way merge. Whitespace changes mixed with other changes to a line are not ignored. See also git-diff(1) -b, -w, and --ignore-space-at-eol.

o If their version only introduces whitespace changes to a line, our version is used;

o If our version introduces whitespace changes but their version includes a substantial change, their version is used;

o Otherwise, the merge proceeds in the usual way.

However, when in a rebase, theirs and ours are swapped from their usual meaning. This means that in my rebase, all my whitespace changes are lost, since they are on their side of the merge.

How do I get git-rebase to keep my whitespace changes?

Sort of. I found a way to end up rebased, without the merge being totally awful, which is probably what you wanted. (It's what I wanted originally.) — D0SBoots, Jan 06 '19 at 19:40

D0SBoots · Accepted Answer · 2019-01-06T19:43:59.347

There's a way, but it's ugly. You're much better off keeping whitespace and "real" changes separate, and upstreaming the former first before doing the latter. But if you find yourself in this situation...

For the sake of simplicity, I am assuming that everything is in a single commit in the current branch. This should work in a multi-commit situation, it just (again) will be more ugly. I'm also assuming the branch to rebase onto is master, and your working branch forked from it somewhere down the line.

git merge master -Xignore-all-space --no-commit. Resolve the merge to your satisfaction.
rm .git/MERGE_*. We're going to convince git that this is a regular commit, not a merge.
git commit -a -m "Pseudo-merge from master"
git rebase -i HEAD^^ and "fixup" the last change into your original one. We could have combined this with the previous step, but actually committing the pseudo-merge gives us a commit to reset to in case something goes wrong later. If this is a multiple-commit change you're working with, you may want/need to move the psuedo-merge change to a different point in the history before you squash it, to properly simulate the rebase.
git rebase HEAD^ --onto master -Xtheirs The "-Xtheirs" says to always prefer their changes, but "ours" and "theirs" are flipped in a rebase, so that means to always prefer ours. This is safe, since we manually resolved the rebase (via merge) already.

Thanks for sharing! It’s definitely not a standard workflow, but on the other hand an impressive trick — epologee, Jan 07 '19 at 06:17

score 0 · Answer 2 · answered Oct 01 '14 at 16:39

0

I guess your only option is to use a git merge instead, this way it doesn't swap theirs and ours.

answered Oct 01 '14 at 16:39

Grzenio

35,875
47
158
240

Need git rebase -Xignore-all-space to preserve my space

2 Answers2

Linked