Does scipy support multithreading for sparse matrix multiplication when using MKL BLAS?

Question

According to MKL BLAS documentation "All matrix-matrix operations (level 3) are threaded for both dense and sparse BLAS." http://software.intel.com/en-us/articles/parallelism-in-the-intel-math-kernel-library

I have built Scipy with MKL BLAS. Using the test code below, I see the expected multithreaded speedup for dense, but not sparse, matrix multiplication. Are there any changes to Scipy to enable multithreaded sparse operations?

# test dense matrix multiplication
from numpy import *
import time    
x = random.random((10000,10000))
t1 = time.time()
foo = dot(x.T, x)
print time.time() - t1

# test sparse matrix multiplication
from scipy import sparse
x = sparse.rand(10000,10000)
t1 = time.time()
foo = dot(x.T, x)
print time.time() - t1

Answer 1

As far as I know, the answer is no. But, you can build your own wrapper around the MKL sparse multiply routines. You asked about the multiplying two sparse matrices. Below is some a wrapper code I used for multiplying one sparse matrix times a dense vector, so it shouldn't be hard to adapt (look at the Intel MKL reference for mkl_cspblas_dcsrgemm). Also, be aware of how your scipy arrays are stored: default is coo, but csr (or csc) may be better choices. I chose csr, but MKL supports most types (just call the appropriate routine).

From what I could tell, both scipy's default and MKL are multithreaded. By changing OMP_NUM_THREADS I could see a difference in performance.

To use the function below, if you havea a recent version of MKL, just make sure you have LD_LIBRARY_PATHS set to include the relevant MKL directories. For older versions, you need to build some specific libraries. I got my information from IntelMKL in python

def SpMV_viaMKL( A, x ):
 """
 Wrapper to Intel's SpMV
 (Sparse Matrix-Vector multiply)
 For medium-sized matrices, this is 4x faster
 than scipy's default implementation
 Stephen Becker, April 24 2014
 stephen.beckr@gmail.com
 """

 import numpy as np
 import scipy.sparse as sparse
 from ctypes import POINTER,c_void_p,c_int,c_char,c_double,byref,cdll
 mkl = cdll.LoadLibrary("libmkl_rt.so")

 SpMV = mkl.mkl_cspblas_dcsrgemv
 # Dissecting the "cspblas_dcsrgemv" name:
 # "c" - for "c-blas" like interface (as opposed to fortran)
 #    Also means expects sparse arrays to use 0-based indexing, which python does
 # "sp"  for sparse
 # "d"   for double-precision
 # "csr" for compressed row format
 # "ge"  for "general", e.g., the matrix has no special structure such as symmetry
 # "mv"  for "matrix-vector" multiply

 if not sparse.isspmatrix_csr(A):
     raise Exception("Matrix must be in csr format")
 (m,n) = A.shape

 # The data of the matrix
 data    = A.data.ctypes.data_as(POINTER(c_double))
 indptr  = A.indptr.ctypes.data_as(POINTER(c_int))
 indices = A.indices.ctypes.data_as(POINTER(c_int))

 # Allocate output, using same conventions as input
 nVectors = 1
 if x.ndim is 1:
    y = np.empty(m,dtype=np.double,order='F')
    if x.size != n:
        raise Exception("x must have n entries. x.size is %d, n is %d" % (x.size,n))
 elif x.shape[1] is 1:
    y = np.empty((m,1),dtype=np.double,order='F')
    if x.shape[0] != n:
        raise Exception("x must have n entries. x.size is %d, n is %d" % (x.size,n))
 else:
    nVectors = x.shape[1]
    y = np.empty((m,nVectors),dtype=np.double,order='F')
    if x.shape[0] != n:
        raise Exception("x must have n entries. x.size is %d, n is %d" % (x.size,n))

 # Check input
 if x.dtype.type is not np.double:
    x = x.astype(np.double,copy=True)
 # Put it in column-major order, otherwise for nVectors > 1 this FAILS completely
 if x.flags['F_CONTIGUOUS'] is not True:
    x = x.copy(order='F')

 if nVectors == 1:
    np_x = x.ctypes.data_as(POINTER(c_double))
    np_y = y.ctypes.data_as(POINTER(c_double))
    # now call MKL. This returns the answer in np_y, which links to y
    SpMV(byref(c_char("N")), byref(c_int(m)),data ,indptr, indices, np_x, np_y ) 
 else:
    for columns in xrange(nVectors):
        xx = x[:,columns]
        yy = y[:,columns]
        np_x = xx.ctypes.data_as(POINTER(c_double))
        np_y = yy.ctypes.data_as(POINTER(c_double))
        SpMV(byref(c_char("N")), byref(c_int(m)),data,indptr, indices, np_x, np_y ) 

 return y

Answer 2

Think this is an answer to the question: https://stackoverflow.com/a/75663143/9569654

Basically, there is a Python wrapper that allows for multithreaded sparse matrix operations with the intel MKL library (https://pypi.org/project/sparse-dot-mkl/). Can be installed using conda as well (https://anaconda.org/conda-forge/sparse_dot_mkl)!