@hornzach - You were so close and with a much simpler answer than the rest.
To hide the error message in (win 7 at least) redirect to the standard error output (2) to nul (a special file, that quietly discards the output "bit-bucket")
set /a varCheck = %var% 2>nul
Then the rest of your answer works for the 4 test cases.
Full Answer With Test Cases:
call :CheckNumeric AA "#NOT A VALID NUMBER"
call :CheckNumeric A1 "#NOT A VALID NUMBER"
call :CheckNumeric 1A "#NOT A VALID NUMBER"
call :CheckNumeric 11 "#A VALID NUMBER"
call :CheckNumeric 1.23456789012345678901234567890.123456 "#NOT A VALID NUMBER"
goto :EOF
:CheckNumeric
@ECHO.
@ECHO Test %1
set /a num=%1 2>nul
if {%num%}=={%1} (
@ECHO %1 #A VALID NUMBER, Expected %2
goto :EOF
)
:INVALID
@ECHO %1 #NOT A VALID NUMBER, Expected %2
Outputs:
Test AA
AA #NOT A VALID NUMBER, Expected "#NOT A VALID NUMBER"
Test A1
A1 #NOT A VALID NUMBER, Expected "#NOT A VALID NUMBER"
Test 1A
1A #NOT A VALID NUMBER, Expected "#NOT A VALID NUMBER"
Test 11
11 #A VALID NUMBER, Expected "#A VALID NUMBER"
Test 1.23456789012345678901234567890.123456
1.23456789012345678901234567890.123456 #NOT A VALID NUMBER, Expected "#NOT A VALID NUMBER"