Why does putting parentheses around a list of comma separated values change the assignment?

Question

Please consider following code,

    int i;

    i = 1,2,3,4,5;
    printf("First time i = %d\n",i);

    i = (1,2,3,4,5);
    printf("Second time i = %d\n",i);

Output:

First time i = 1

Second time i = 5

Why do the parentheses make the comma operator take last value and without parentheses it takes first value?

Thanks in advance.

[This may help](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comma_operator). Check `Examples` heading on this Page. — Dayal rai, Jul 15 '13 at 07:18
@ar2015 i can clearly see answer lies in _Examples_ section from provided link where `i = (a,b)` and `i = a,b` is discussed. — Dayal rai, Oct 03 '15 at 07:51

score 21 · Accepted Answer · answered Jul 15 '13 at 07:13

21

First one is equivalent to (i = 1),2,3,4,5; which means the commas have no effect. When used with parentheses it returns the last value in the "comma delimited list"

This is all due to operator precedence, which you can view a table about here

answered Jul 15 '13 at 07:13

Rapptz

20,807
5
72
86

Agreed, but why last value? – Pranit Kothari Jul 15 '13 at 07:15
2

@pranitkothari Because the comma has the lowest operator precedence and parentheses groups them together. The comma operator has a left-to-right associativity. – Rapptz Jul 15 '13 at 07:17

Filip Roséen - refp · Answer 2 · 2013-07-15T07:21:12.813

9

This is due to the operator precedence and the order of evaluation. = binds harder than , and from that we can figure out that the below two expressions are the same:

i = 1,2,3,4,5 /* <- same as -> */ (i = 1),(2),(3),(4),(5)

^{side-note: the comma operator is the "weakest" operator of them all}

Why does the comma operator yield the last value of our list?

To put it simple this operator evaluate the first operand only to discard it and move on to the next one, it binds left-to-right which means that it will start from the left, and continue walking towards the right.

Where can I read more about this topic?

edited Jul 15 '13 at 07:21

answered Jul 15 '13 at 07:13

Filip Roséen - refp

62,493
20
150
196

1

+1 for mentioning operator precedence – junix Jul 15 '13 at 07:15
1

+1 Nice explanation, but really sorry, chosen anther as answer. – Pranit Kothari Jul 15 '13 at 07:27

AllTooSir · Answer 3 · 2013-07-15T07:19:28.597

Assignment has higher precedence than comma , hence the result you get in the first case. You can find the entire operator precedence table here .

Why parenthesis makes comma operator to take last value and without parenthesis it takes first value?

Because parenthesis is used to override the precedence. The first case is implicitly equivalent to :

(i = 1),2,3,4,5;

Comma evaluates from left to right and the rightmost value is the value of the entire expression. Read the documentation here.

The comma operator has left-to-right associativity. Two expressions separated by a comma are evaluated left to right. The left operand is always evaluated, and all side effects are completed before the right operand is evaluated.

Mark Garcia · Answer 4 · 2013-07-15T07:27:29.980

Because = has a higher precedence than , (which has the lowest), the first is the same as

(i = 1),2,3,4,5;

which assigns 1 to i (i = 1) then evaluating the expressions 2, 3, 4, and 5 through the comma operators (the whole expression actually results in 5, which is not used). In the second one,

(1,2,3,4,5)

is parenthesized, therefore it will be first evaluated before =. It results in 5 (the right-most expression; this is the behavior of the comma operator) which is then assigned to i.

i = (1,2,3,4,5);
    |         |
    \---------\--- results in 5 then is assigned to i

See operator precedence Wikipedia article.

Why does putting parentheses around a list of comma separated values change the assignment?

4 Answers4

Linked

Related