Is ClickOnce still the way to go for Windows Forms application deployment?

Question

I've just been looking for books that cover ClickOnce deployment and there don't seem to be many at all out there, and the ones that are are a few years old(?).

Additional notes re what I'm doing:

An executable and one database file (SQLite)
Database (SQLite) will need to be updated sometimes by the application (e.g. add table, add column)
Database data (which is just a file for SQLite) needs to remain across upgrades of course

score 9 · Accepted Answer · answered Mar 02 '10 at 18:01

ClickOnce is still an amazing technology. It takes care of a large amount of heavy lifting from your side, but takes away some customizations that you can use with the Windows Installer.

Directly from the words of MS, ClickOnce overcomes three issues in deployment:

Difficulties in updating applications. With Microsoft Windows Installer deployment, whenever an application is updated, the user must reinstall the entire application; with ClickOnce deployment, you can provide updates automatically. Only those portions of the application that have changed are downloaded, then the full, updated application is reinstalled from a new side-by-side folder.
Impact to the user's computer. With Windows Installer deployment, applications often rely on shared components, with the potential for versioning conflicts; with ClickOnce deployment, each application is self-contained and cannot interfere with other applications.
Security permissions. Windows Installer deployment requires administrative permissions and allows only limited user installation; ClickOnce deployment allows non-administrative users to install and grants only those Code Access Security permissions necessary for the application.

I recommend giving this a thorough read: MSDN - ClickOnce Deployment. Also, if it's good enough for Google (Chrome), it's good enough for most of us ;)

True, but between the first two points, I still reckon it's worthwhile. — Kyle Rosendo, Mar 02 '10 at 18:20

score 5 · Answer 2 · edited May 08 '16 at 15:40

5

It depends what you need to deploy; if it's a single executable with possibly a couple of content files then yes, but if you need custom scripts, installing services, etc. then I would highly suggest looking into Windows Installer.

edited May 08 '16 at 15:40

Peter Mortensen

30,738
21
105
131

answered Mar 02 '10 at 17:56

Michal Ciechan

13,492
11
76
118

what about an executable and one database file (sqlite) with the assumption the database (sqlite) will need to be updates sometimes by the application (e.g. add table, add column), and the data needs remain across upgrades of course - will clickonce work here for a user who does not have Admin rights? – Greg Mar 02 '10 at 23:40
have added this last question as a question in it's own right at http://stackoverflow.com/questions/2369025/clickonce-does-writing-reading-to-the-data-directory-required-admin-rights – Greg Mar 03 '10 at 05:46

score 2 · Answer 3 · edited Aug 22 '14 at 13:48

The answer may also depend on where you are deploying? Are you writing an internally used application for a company, where everyone has access to an internet share that you can deploy your ClickOnce too? If yes, then ClickOnce is great.

If you are trying to write shrink-wrap software for general consumption, then creating a deployment project that distills down to an MSI, or even using a product like InstallShield or NSIS (does that still exist?) may be your better option.

score 1 · Answer 4 · edited May 08 '16 at 15:50

ClickOnce is great if you're OK with the limitations. If you've got a Windows application that doesn't need the full-blown MSI over-engineered madness, by all means use ClickOnce.

ClickOnce takes care of auto-updates, and it takes care of previous versions and rollbacks. ClickOnce installs/uninstalls take seconds, far faster than traditional MSIs. The benefits are many, so if you're OK with the constraints, by all means you should use it.

Is ClickOnce still the way to go for Windows Forms application deployment?

4 Answers4

Linked