Cin without waiting for input?

Question

For a project I am working on, I need the program to be able to receive input from the user, but while they are inputting something, the program can continue in the loop.

For example:

while (true)
{
    if (userInput == true)
    {
        cin >> input
    }
    //DO SOMETHING
}

This would mean that //DO SOMETHING would happen every loop, without the user pressing enter a million times.

Before, my solution was creating my own input using kbhit() and getch() from conio.h, but that got very messy, and I don't like using conio.h for portability reasons etc. Also, it doesn't need to use cin specifically, because there is a good chance it just wouldn't work with it, so any good solution that doesn't require me making my own input with a 'not very good' library, would be much appreciated.

Answer 1

It could be worth looking into multi-threading for this. I'm usually hesitant to suggest it, because multithreading pulls in a host of potential problems that can end up difficult to debug, but in this case they can be isolated fairly easily. I envision something like this:

#include <atomic>
#include <chrono>
#include <iostream>
#include <thread>

int main() {
  std::atomic<bool> interrupted;
  int x;
  int i = 0;

  do {
    interrupted.store(false);

    // create a new thread that does stuff in the background
    std::thread th([&]() {
        while(!interrupted) {
          // do stuff. Just as an example:
          std::cout << i << std::flush;
          std::this_thread::sleep_for(std::chrono::milliseconds(100));
        }
      });

    std::cin >> x;

    // when input is complete, interrupt thread and wait for it to finish
    interrupted.store(true);
    th.join();

    // apply x, then loop to make new thread to do stuff
    i = x;
  } while(x != -1); // or some other exit condition
}

At first glance this looks somewhat wasteful because it keeps spawning and throwing threads away, but user input takes, in computing terms, an eternity, so the overhead should not be prohibitive. More importantly, it does have the advantage of avoiding any suggestion of data races wholesale because the only means of communication between the main (input) loop and the background thread is the atomic interruption flag, and the application of x to shared data happens when no thread is running that could race the main loop.

Answer 2

Disclaimer: the following seems to be working with gcc on Linux, however for some reasons it does not work with VC++ on Windows. The specifications appear to give a lot of leeway to the implementations here, and VC++ definitely takes advantage of it...

There are multiple functions available on any std::basic_istream or its underlying std::basic_streambuf.

In order to know if there is any character available for input, you may call in_avail on std::basic_streambuf:

if (std::cin.rdbuf() and std::cin.rdbuf()->in_avail() >= 0) {
}

in_avail gives you the number of characters available without blocking, it returns -1 if there is no such character. Afterward, you can use the regular "formatted" read operations such as std::cin >> input.

Otherwise, for unformatted reads, you can use readsome from std::basic_istream, which returns up to N characters available without blocking:

size_t const BufferSize = 512;
char buffer[BufferSize];

if (std::cin.readsome(buffer, BufferSize) >= 1) {
}

However it is noted that the implementation of this method is highly variable, so for a portable program it might not be that useful.

Note: as mentioned in the comment, the in_avail approach might be spotty. I confirm it can work, however you first have to use an obscure feature of C++ IO streams: std::ios_base::sync_with_stdio(false) which allows C++ streams to buffer input (and thus steal it from C's stdio buffers).

Answer 3

It's sad that there is no simple portable way to checking asynchronously if a key was hit. But I guess that the standard committee has carefully evaluated the pros and cons.

If you don't want to rely on third party event management libraries, and if multithreading would be overkill, one alternative could be to have your own version of kbhit(), with conditional compiling for the environments you want to support:

• if your conio.h supports kbhit() just use it.
• for windows, you can refer to _kbhit()
• for linux and posix, you can use Matthieu's answer, or look here for Morgan Mattews's code

It's not the most academic answer, but it's pragmatic.

Answer 4

Maybe, you can have a try:

while (true)
{
    if (userInput == true)
    {
        if(cin >> input){
        }else{
            std::cout << "Invalid input!" << std::endl;
            cin.clear();
        }
    }
    //DO SOMETHING
}