Is there a Java or Scala equivalent to Cucumber/SpecFlow? One possibility is using Cucumber with JRuby; any others?
-
1Perhaps http://stackoverflow.com/questions/1068785/which-bdd-framework-for-java-do-you-use might be helpful. – Mark Jun 08 '10 at 20:14
-
1Have you looked at the frameworks available? Just for Scala, ScalaTest has BDD support, and Specs was designed with BDD in mind. Then there's a multitude of testing frameworks for Java. Perhaps if you could explain your requirements a bit better, it would be easier to answer this question. – Daniel C. Sobral Jun 08 '10 at 22:02
6 Answers
Take a look at ScalaTest with Feature Spec. Sample feature spec from the ScalaTest website:
import org.scalatest.FeatureSpec
import org.scalatest.GivenWhenThen
import scala.collection.mutable.Stack
class ExampleSpec extends FeatureSpec with GivenWhenThen {
feature("The user can pop an element off the top of the stack") {
info("As a programmer")
info("I want to be able to pop items off the stack")
info("So that I can get them in last-in-first-out order")
scenario("pop is invoked on a non-empty stack") {
given("a non-empty stack")
val stack = new Stack[Int]
stack.push(1)
stack.push(2)
val oldSize = stack.size
when("when pop is invoked on the stack")
val result = stack.pop()
then("the most recently pushed element should be returned")
assert(result === 2)
and("the stack should have one less item than before")
assert(stack.size === oldSize - 1)
}
scenario("pop is invoked on an empty stack") {
given("an empty stack")
val emptyStack = new Stack[String]
when("when pop is invoked on the stack")
then("NoSuchElementException should be thrown")
intercept[NoSuchElementException] {
emptyStack.pop()
}
and("the stack should still be empty")
assert(emptyStack.isEmpty)
}
}
}

- 23,534
- 11
- 81
- 97
specs provides Literate Specifications with "forms" to develop Fit-like specifications. You can find a post explaining the rationale of it here, and some examples of what can be done with it.
Note however that the library is still in alpha mode as I plan to give it more attention once Scala 2.8.0 has settled.

- 15,494
- 38
- 61
Now you can use Cucumber and define your steps in Java or pure Scala.
Here you have a short and easy tutorial on how to use it in Scala with SBT: http://func.io/post/36452127031/pure-scala-bdd-made-easy-with-sbt-and-cucumber.

- 113
- 4
JBehave works just fine with Scala. For an example, in this article, http://jnb.ociweb.com/jnb/jnbJun2010.html there is a link to a zip file that contains a sample application using JBehave implemented completely in Scala.
Direct link to zip: http://www.ociweb.com/jnb/jnbJun2010-scala-bowling.zip

- 357
- 1
- 4
Look at Fitness, if you want to separate test code from acceptance text. Otherwise, both Specs and ScalaTest support BDD-style (Specs was written to be BDD-style), and lots of other Java frameworks support it was well.

- 295,120
- 86
- 501
- 681
JBehave was rewritten after Cucumber was released, so that we could also use plain text. Gherkin wasn't out when we wrote it, so it doesn't parse exactly the same - uses tokens instead of regexp - but it'll do the same job.

- 17,277
- 4
- 47
- 92