Finding object by index, HashMaps or looping through an ArrayList? Which is fastest? (Java)

Question

Currently in my game, if I want to find a player by their unique id I do something like this:

public Player getPlayerByID (int id) {
    for (Player player : playerList) {
        if (player.getId() == id)
            return player;
    }
    return null;
}

Would using a java HashMap be faster for indexing a player? Using something like this:

HashMap<Integer, Player> playerMap = new HashMap<Integer, Player>();

//Some method to fill hash map with players...

//Get player method
public Player getPlayerByID (int id) {
    playerMap.get(id);
}