Best way to retrieve the number of elements in a vector in matlab

Question

I would like to know what is the best way to retrieve the number of element in a vector in matlab in term of speed:

is it:

length(A)

or

size(A,1)

There is also `numel` which is pretty fast. Have a look at [this](http://stackoverflow.com/questions/3119739/difference-between-matlabs-numel-and-length-functions) question for a short discussion — Benoit_11, Jul 14 '16 at 12:53

Suever · Accepted Answer · 2016-07-14T13:46:37.850

3

Neither. You want to always use numel for this purpose. length only returns the longest dimension (which can get confusing for 2D arrays) and size(data, dimension) requires you to know whether it's a row or column vector. numel will return the number of elements whether it is a row vector, column vector, or multi-dimensional array.

We can easily test the performance of these by writing a quick benchmark. We will take the size with the various methods N times (for this I used 10000).

function size_test

    nRepeats = 10000;

    times1 = zeros(nRepeats, 1);
    times2 = zeros(nRepeats, 1);
    times3 = zeros(nRepeats, 1);

    for k = 1:nRepeats
        data = rand(10000, 1);
        tic
        size(data, 1);
        times1(k) = toc;
        tic
        length(data);
        times2(k) = toc;
        tic
        numel(data);
        times3(k) = toc;
    end

    % Compute the total time required for each method
    fprintf('size:\t%0.8f\n', sum(times1));
    fprintf('length:\t%0.8f\n', sum(times2));
    fprintf('numel:\t%0.8f\n', sum(times3));
end

When run on my machine it yields:

size:   0.00860400
length: 0.00626700
numel:  0.00617300

So in addition to being the most robust, numel is also slightly faster than the other alternatives.

That being said, there are likely many other bottlenecks in your code than determining the number of elements in an array so I would focus on optimizing those.

edited Jul 14 '16 at 13:46

answered Jul 14 '16 at 12:57

Suever

64,497
14
82
101

I posted the same answer but then I removed it. The OP wrote `vector` instead of `matrix`. I think he is considering that one of the dimension of the matrix is one! – Sardar Usama Jul 14 '16 at 13:09
@Sardar_Usama It doesn't matter. The answer is always `numel` regardless. – Suever Jul 14 '16 at 13:10
`length(A)` and `size(A,1)` or `size(A,2)` also do the same if one of the dimension of the matrix is one. That's what I mean – Sardar Usama Jul 14 '16 at 13:11
@Sardar_Usama I realize they all yield the same result, but `numel` is the correct / most robust way. – Suever Jul 14 '16 at 13:12
@Sardar_Usama Added a benchmark to demonstrate the actual performance benefits of `numel` as well. – Suever Jul 14 '16 at 13:49
Your answers are always the best! – Sardar Usama Jul 14 '16 at 13:52

Best way to retrieve the number of elements in a vector in matlab

1 Answers1