Ruby: @@ vs @ variables outside of classes?

Question

I understand that a variable declared with @ outside of a class will become an instance variable of the object main.

Functionally, is this any different than declaring it as @@?

I was expecting @test declared in file2.rb to throw an exception when accessed in file1.rb (through require), but it did not. Does this mean there is always only one main object and that @ and @@ are equivalent in this scope?

score 0 · Answer 1 · edited May 23 '17 at 12:08

0

No, they certainly are not equivalent:

@foo = 'bar'
instance_variables
# => [:@prompt, :@foo]

@@bar = 'baz'
# warning: class variable access from toplevel
instance_variables
# => [:@prompt, :@foo]

When you require a file, it assumes the context of the require line. I.e.:

# file1.rb
@foo = 'bar'

# file2.rb
puts instance_variables

# irb
require './file1'
require './file2'
# => [:@prompt, :@foo]

main is simply an instance of Object. You can read more about main here.

edited May 23 '17 at 12:08

Community

1
1

answered Aug 11 '16 at 16:28

coreyward

77,547
20
137
166

Thanks.. though this has me wondering, if it's not a scope gate, why can't I access plain variables declared in file2 in the script calling require? – kehtyr Aug 11 '16 at 16:34
@kehtyr You're right, I misspoke. Each file is defined within its own local scope, much like method scope boundaries. They are within the same `main` instance, though. – coreyward Aug 11 '16 at 16:54

score 0 · Accepted Answer · answered Aug 11 '16 at 16:41

I understand that a variable declared with @ outside of a class will become an instance variable of the object main.

Functionally, is this any different than declaring it as @@?

Yes, it is. @ is an instance variable, @@ is a class variable. At the top-level, @ is an instance variable of the main object, @@ is a class variable of Object:

@@foo = :bar
# warning: class variable access from toplevel

Object.class_variables
# => [:@@foo]

I was expecting @test declared in file2.rb to throw an exception when accessed in file1.rb (through require), but it did not.

This has actually nothing to do with your question: instance variables never raise an Exception when accessed, even when they don't exist. They simply evaluate to nil in that case.

Does this mean there is always only one main object

Yes, there is one main object.

and that @ and @@ are equivalent in this scope?

No, they are not. @ at the top-level is an instance variable of main, @@ at the top-level is a class variable of Object. And since class variables are inherited by all subclasses and all instances of the class and all its subclasses and (almost) all classes are subclasses of Object and (almost) all objects are (indirect) instances of Object, this means that top-level @@ is an (almost) global variable.

So, the scopes of top-level @ and @@ are very different!

Ruby: @@ vs @ variables outside of classes?

2 Answers2