x=('hello world' "HELLO")
Both ${#x[*]} and ${#x[@]} print the same output.
I understand the difference between $@ and $* but I am interested to see the difference without command line arguments.
Asked
Active
Viewed 75 times
-2
Suraj
- 27
- 7
-
`${#...}` doesn't subject the contents of the array to further shell expansion, so those two expressions *are* identical. – chepner Oct 29 '16 at 13:40
1 Answers
0
Always use @ expansion unless you have reason to use *. @ was added to work around a problem.
The two don't ALWAYS expand the same. The troubles involving* start with spaces and other shell metacharacters (quotes in particular, but $ and more as well).
The * leaves the metacharacters open for the shell to process them again, which is usually bad if you went out of your way to get them into the array. The @ protects them by expanding each array element as if it was a separately quoted value, leaving all metacharacters intact.
Gilbert
- 3,740
- 17
- 19