15

For Spring what if I have two requests that access the singleton bean at the same time? Does one request have to wait until the other to finish. How does Spring container find the singleton bean instance for my requests?

For servlets if I have two requests that access a normal class's normal method(no static no other complex things) at the same time? Does one request have to wait until the other to finish to avoid concurrency (at the same time two request are trying to access the object of the same class). How does web container find the instance for my requests?

Mistalis
  • 17,793
  • 13
  • 73
  • 97
008ak89
  • 325
  • 1
  • 3
  • 8
  • 2
    There's no waiting involved unless you perform some kind of `synchronization` to prevent multiple threads from executing a method at the same time. – Kayaman Dec 16 '16 at 08:00

1 Answers1

24

For Spring, what if I have two requests that access the singleton bean at the same time? Does one request have to wait until the other to finish?

Spring container creates one and only one instance for the singleton bean class (like for Controller, Service class, etc..). In Java, there are several ways that you can create singleton instance for a class safely, you can look here for more on this. Once the singleton instance is created by the Spring container then the web requests will be served using that single instance of the controller/service classes.

Also, there is no problem (i.e., there will not be any waits in between) even if two requests access the singleton bean as they will be served in two separate threads and all you need to ensure is that your controller and service classes (i.e., singleton scoped beans) do not carry/hold any state (i.e., they are stateless) and are thread-safe.

How does Spring container find the singleton bean instance for my requests?

Spring container creates and then injects the singleton bean instances based upon the configurations that you have provided using the xml or through annotations.

For servlets, if I have two requests that access a normal class's normal method(no static no other complex things) at the same time? Does one request have to wait until the other to finish to avoid concurrency (at the same time two request are trying to access the object of the same class) ?

No, each request will be handled in a separate thread so one request will not wait for the other request to be served/completed i.e., in other words, the requests will be served/processed parallelly. This is achieved by the Web containers by using/managing the Thread pools.

How does web container find the instance for my requests?

Web container (like Tomcat, etc..) creates and loads all of the servlet classes (like Spring's DispatcherServlet or your own custom servlets) and then once the web request comes from the client (like Browser), it will be handled to the servlet according the url-pattern configured in the web.xml or through annotations.

Community
  • 1
  • 1
Vasu
  • 21,832
  • 11
  • 51
  • 67
  • 1
    You should said that the singleton bean shall be stateless and that all methods have to be thread safe... – Serge Ballesta Dec 16 '16 at 08:47
  • Now for servlets according to ur answer if request are handled by two separate threads then how one thread ensures that the state of object its getting is not modified by other thread? (if u dont understand my point u can clarify).. – 008ak89 Dec 16 '16 at 16:09