7

I am aware of this question (Can Windows Containers be hosted on linux?), but it doesn't really answer my question.

I am new to Docker, but my question is such - if I take any windows application, put it inside a Docker container, can it run now on Linux and vice versa?

Confluent claims that it can run only on linux, but my colleague installed it on Windows using Docker. So if you can install it with Docker, then the whole application would surely be regarded as cross platform?

I think I am missing some important point here.

eddyP23
  • 6,420
  • 7
  • 49
  • 87

1 Answers1

11

Docker is not a VM, it's a way to run applications on a shared kernel that isolate those applications from each other. Windows binaries don't run on a Linux kernel, and vice versa (ignoring the Linux runtime for Windows for the time being). So if you build a container with your Windows application, it will only run if you did so on Dockers Windows runtime and windows base image. It's won't run on a Linux host.

What docker does provide is an embedded VM running Linux (originally this was VirtualBox, but current versions are HyperV). By running Docker for Windows, by default, this VM was used and you would only be running Linux containers, so your windows application would not even run inside the container. To run the Windows binaries, you need to toggle Docker for Windows to use the Windows runtime, and presently that's a toggle, you can't run both Linux and Windows runtimes concurrently on the same host.

There also is no Windows VM packaged with Docker's Linux install. You would need to install your own copy of Windows (and get the licensing which is why Docker doesn't ship this) inside a VM on a Linux host and run your containers inside that VM if you need Windows support.

BMitch
  • 231,797
  • 42
  • 475
  • 450
  • 1
    So am I correct in the following: Docker basically runs Linux VM and everything you run on Docker has to be Linux containers, unless you toggle Docker to run Windows VM and then you can run Windows containers inside it? Is there a Windows VM Docker that runs on Linux? – eddyP23 Sep 12 '17 at 06:15
  • @eddyP23 You're following correct, docker does not provide a Windows VM for Linux environments. – BMitch Sep 12 '17 at 11:58
  • Thanks. I wanted to understand how docker runs linux images on windows and if it has a linux runtime. your answer seem to say that Docker runs images on Linux VM – Manu Chadha Dec 25 '19 at 21:35
  • @ManuChadha docker itself isn't a VM, but the desktop tools ship a VM that includes docker to run Linux containers on non-Linux hosts. – BMitch Dec 26 '19 at 02:23