nuget.exe doesn't return all versions of specified package

Question

I'm using the latest stable version of nuget.exe (4.3.0) and attempting to get all versions of a package.

This returns only one version:

nuget.exe list OBeautifulCode.Math.HashCodeHelper -allversions -prerelease -includedelisted -source "https://api.nuget.org/v3/index.json"

output:

OBeautifulCode.Math.HashCodeHelper 1.0.52

Same if I remove -prerelease and -includedelisted

nuget.org has multiple versions of this package (including delisted and pre-release and non-pre-release versions): OBeautifulCode.Math.HashCodeHelper

What am I doing wrong?