evaluating methods of libc++ in gdb when using clang

Question

When compiling this

#include <vector>
#include <stdio.h>
int main()
{
    std::vector<int> foo;
    foo.push_back( 1 );
    printf( "%zu\n", foo.size() );
}

with clang++ foo.cpp -stdlib=libc++ -g, when running a.out in gdb and trying to show the result of foo.size(), gdb says "Cannot evaluate function -- may be inlined".

Is there a way to avoid the compiler's inlining in debug mode? I could use libstdc++, but it is quite painful when it is needed to go inside the templates (many many subcalls plus indentation is sometimes space-based and sometimes tab-based).

I am running with Debian 9 (stretch) using libc++-dev v3.5 with clang 3.8 (tried with clang 5.0 too, same result) and gdb 7.12.

Possible duplicate https://stackoverflow.com/q/22163730/817643 — StoryTeller - Unslander Monica, Mar 06 '18 at 10:55
I must admit I didn't noticed this one, but here there is at least 2 differences: it works with libstdc++, and the inlining is not under my control. — user3459474, Mar 06 '18 at 11:15

score 3 · Accepted Answer · answered Mar 06 '18 at 15:17

libstdc++ implements so called Python xmethods, see documentation:

Xmethods are additional methods or replacements for existing methods of a C++ class. This feature is useful for those cases where a method defined in C++ source code could be inlined or optimized out by the compiler, making it unavailable to GDB. For such cases, one can define an xmethod to serve as a replacement for the method defined in the C++ source code. GDB will then invoke the xmethod, instead of the C++ method, to evaluate expressions. One can also use xmethods when debugging with core files. Moreover, when debugging live programs, invoking an xmethod need not involve running the inferior (which can potentially perturb its state). Hence, even if the C++ method is available, it is better to use its replacement xmethod if one is defined.

That's why you can call mock foo.size() even if the real foo.size() was inlined by compiler when using libstdc++. As far as I know there is no alike xmethod implementation for libc++.

evaluating methods of libc++ in gdb when using clang

1 Answers1