I use Swift Frameworks (Cocoa Touch Framework) to segment code into fairly independent modules.I have imported several external libraries, with Cocoapods, into the main app and those modules without any issues so far.
Xcode 9.3
iOS 11.2
CocoaPods 1.5
GoogleToolboxForMac (2.1.3), Firebase (4.13.0), FirebaseAnalytics (4.2.0), FirebaseCore (4.0.20), FirebaseDatabase (4.1.5), FirebaseInstanceID (2.0.10)
However when I import Firebase in any of those modules, in addition to importing it in the main app, my application crashes.
I don't even need to use anything from Firebase in the modules ; simply adding the pod to the target (module Store
in this case) in the Podfile will crash the app as soon as I leave the main window (fira_viewDidDisappear).
There is also a long list of issues during startup (that were also reported by others), all similar to :
objc[36264]: Class FIRAIdentifiers is implemented in both /{$userdir}/Library/Developer/Xcode/DerivedData/FrameWork101-aekmajbumgzabmayoanlcrwtzbcs/Build/Products/Debug-iphonesimulator/Store.framework/Store (0x105478318) and /{$userdir}/Library/Developer/CoreSimulator/Devices/31D920E9-CD46-47C4-9631-503B3471AAF7/data/Containers/Bundle/Application/57B8020D-E2AB-4A06-B654-5F26F8E00AF6/FrameWork101.app/FrameWork101 (0x103b1ef80). One of the two will be used. Which one is undefined.
Pretty ominous statement...
There are several threads somewhat related to this :
- How do I Integrate the Firebase cocoaPods in my custom swift framework?
- Building a swift Cocoa Touch framework with Firebase as a dependency
And even an issue (#6619) filed...
But they don't have a clear resolution / answer and the issue has even been closed without any resolution.
So is there a way to use Firebase in a modular approach (using frameworks) ? If so what's the best way to make this works ? Or is the Firebase SDK too invasive to do so ?
Thanks !
Podfile :
project 'FrameWork101.xcodeproj'
platform :ios, '11.2'
target 'Binding' do
use_frameworks!
pod 'ReactiveKit'
pod 'Bond'
end
target 'Model' do
use_frameworks!
target 'ModelTests' do
inherit! :search_paths
end
end
target 'Service' do
use_frameworks!
pod 'ReactiveKit'
pod 'Bond'
end
target 'View' do
use_frameworks!
pod 'ReactiveKit'
pod 'Bond'
end
target 'Store' do
use_frameworks!
pod 'ReactiveKit'
pod 'Bond'
pod 'Firebase/Database' <---- comment this out and it works fine.
end
target 'FrameWork101' do
use_frameworks!
pod 'Firebase/Core'
pod 'ReactiveKit'
pod 'Bond'
target 'FrameWork101Tests' do
inherit! :search_paths
end
end
And part of the crash report :