Ignoring column with the highest value where substring matches

Question

I have a table similar to this in my application, i am trying to ignore the item "applefritter_demo_rasberry" because its just the sum of all the other items which has the same substring.

I am trying to write a mysql query (not an expert) to fetch all the values except "applefritter_demo_rasberry" which is nothing but a parent to these items and holds the total.

I've looked at the sub string using this post, but i couldn't grasp the logic behind this. Can some one suggest a way.

ID        Recipe                                 Value 
164686    applefritter_demo_rasberry             140                      
164686    applefritter_demo_rasberry_cake        40
164686    applefritter_demo_rasberry_pudding     20
164686    applefritter_demo_rasberry_pie         10
164686    applefritter_demo_rasberry_bread       40
164686    applefritter_demo_rasberry_candy       20
164686    applefritter_demo_rasberry_juice       10

EDIT:

Just to add a bit more clarity to the question, the table is populated by an application, the application also inserted the parent recipe's total and its children's total. I have a requirement to identify the total of all the recipe's in the table, the table also contains standalone recipe (no parent) such as "ovenfresh_frenchbread" , during total calculation i want ignore all these parent items who end up being the substring of child items.

What if one of the "children" were missing and the totals did not add up? — Gordon Linoff, Apr 21 '18 at 14:41
The total has a default value as 0, the items are linked with the "ID" — Sudheej, Apr 21 '18 at 14:42

score 1 · Accepted Answer · answered Apr 21 '18 at 14:43

As I understand the question, you want something like this:

select t.*
from t
where t.value <> (select coalesce(sum(t2.value), 0)
                  from t2
                  where t2.recipe like concat(t.recipe, '_%') and
                        t2.id = t.id
                 );

I am not 100% clear on what the matching logic is in the subquery, whether it is based only on id or also on string matching.

score 0 · Answer 2 · edited Jun 20 '20 at 09:12

You can use the LIKE and NOT LIKE clauses to filter by sequence of characters:

The LIKE clause determines if the string matches a specified pattern. A pattern can include normal characters and wildcards.
NOT LIKE reverses the comparison, verifying that the string does NOT match the specified pattern.

For example:

1. Select all people where names begin with the letter 'c':

SELECT * FROM person WHERE name LIKE 'c%'

2. Select all people where second letter of the name is 'c':

SELECT * FROM person WHERE name LIKE '_c%'

3. Select all persons who have the sequence 'clau' in the name independent to their position:

SELECT * FROM person WHERE name LIKE '%clau%'

4. Select all people where name does not start with the letter 'c':

SELECT * FROM person WHERE name NOT LIKE 'c%'

Your Solution

Going back to your problem, if we use NOT LIKE as below, no results will be returned, because all the items in your column start with this sequence:

SELECT * FROM person WHERE name NOT LIKE '%applefritter_demo_rasberry%'

For your problem the solution would be to use LIKE as follows:

SELECT * FROM person WHERE name LIKE '%applefritter_demo_rasberry_%'

Hope this helps!

score 0 · Answer 3 · answered Apr 21 '18 at 15:48

Consider adding another column Parent holding the ID of the parent, as with the shared IDs it isn't clear which row has which role -- is it a parent or a child? (That is, apart from the substring logic in Recipe which isn't that handy to guarantee integrity as it's hard if not impossible to use in constraints. And is less efficient to query as string operations like LIKE or substring() needed to be involved. Plus it's redundant having the shared ID logic and the substring logic in place at the same time. What's right if they contradict each other?)

Redesigned like that it's easy to query the direct children of a parent. Just select all rows where the Parent is the one you're looking for, e.g.:

SELECT *
       FROM table
       WHERE Parent = 164686;

And think about filling the Value of parents automatically to the sum of their children e.g. by triggers, unless you've done that already. Otherwise that might get inconsistent. Or alternatively only store the value in row without any children and compute the value of a parent by the sum of the values of its children. (Though this can get hairy if there is more than one level of hierarchy involved.)

Ignoring column with the highest value where substring matches

3 Answers3

Your Solution