Why does \n work only in f string when inside print?

Question

I'm working on a school assigment for python/pandas and wanted to try out f strings as seemed very handy way of formatting.

After reading documentation, I realised that I couldn't use \n to format the output. For this code:

    f"Shape of dataset:\n {df.shape} (rows, columns)\n"

I get this output:

Out[38]: 'Shape of dataset:\n (270792, 11) (rows, columns)\n'

Which is exactly what I expected after reading the docs.

But then, when I surround it by a print(), as such:

print(f"Shape of dataset:\n {df.shape} (rows, columns)\n")

I get it looking the way I wanted:

Shape of dataset:
 (270792, 11) (rows, columns)

I know I could just use regular formatting as well, but I'm curious as to why this is. Is it that the f string component is ignored because of the print?

That's not specific to f-strings, displaying the repr of a string is different to printing it. Note you don't see the quotes, either. — jonrsharpe, Apr 25 '19 at 21:39
I'll just leave this here: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/1436703/difference-between-str-and-repr — HFBrowning, Apr 25 '19 at 22:02
Thanks so much for the kind explanations, @jonrsharpe, @cargicenicate and @amanb. And @HFBrowning thanks for the link on the difference between `___str___` and `___repr___`, there is a very clear walkthrough on the intention behind each. — Laura Prado, Apr 26 '19 at 07:42

Carcigenicate · Answer 1 · 2019-04-25T21:46:12.690

This isn't specific to f-strings. This is the result in QPython's REPL on my phone:

>> "\nhello\n" 
'\nhello\n'

If you enter a String into a REPL, escape characters (like "\n") are left as-is. They are only "expressed" when explicitly printed out. Even though the P in REPL stands for "print", the REPL evidently uses a different mechanism for printing, or manually escapes the characters for you before printing to preserve them.

This can be useful when examining strings, since slightly "invisible" characters like newlines and tabs can be difficult to spot in printed output.

amanb · Accepted Answer · 2019-04-25T22:09:34.627

The following are some examples that illustrate the point that when you enter a string into a Python/IPython Repl, the repr form of the string is shown. It does not matter which string formatter you use(f-strings or .format()). However, when you print it, it gets formatted and escapes characters like newlines, tabs etc.

In [18]: f"a\nb\n"
Out[18]: 'a\nb\n'

In [19]: print(f"a\nb\n")
a
b


In [20]: f"a\tb\tc"
Out[20]: 'a\tb\tc'

In [21]: print(f"a\tb\tc")
a       b       c

In [22]: a = 1

In [23]: b=2

In [24]: "a={}\nb={}".format(a,b)
Out[24]: 'a=1\nb=2'

In [25]: print("a={}\nb={}".format(a,b))
a=1
b=2

In [26]: "a={}\tb={}".format(a,b)
Out[26]: 'a=1\tb=2'

In [27]: print("a={}\tb={}".format(a,b))
a=1     b=2

Python provides a repr() function that shows the printable representation of the object. All statements without the print above use this internally in the Python/IPython console. There is also the str() function that formats the object. Internally, when you print the string, str() is applied first that formats the string.

In [29]: print(repr(f"a\tb\tc"))
'a\tb\tc'

In [30]: print(str(f"a\tb\tc"))
a       b       c

Why does \n work only in f string when inside print?

2 Answers2