How properly instantiate static field tat is another class object

Question

If I have in my .h file

class A
{
 ...
protected:
static std::mutex someMutex;
}

What is proper way to instantiate it in the cpp file? Just to write

std::mutex A::someMutex;

? It works, but just such syntax where I basically declare a field twice feels a bit confusing, so I decided to doublecheck asking here, also maybe there are some other(better?) ways?

@MarkRansom yes, it works, but just such syntax where I basically declare a field twice feels a bit confusing, so I decided to doublecheck asking here, also maybe there are some other(better?) ways — DoehJohn, May 30 '20 at 18:31
Does this answer your question? [Static constant string (class member)](https://stackoverflow.com/questions/1563897/static-constant-string-class-member) — JaMiT, May 30 '20 at 20:09

score 1 · Accepted Answer · answered May 30 '20 at 18:46

What you did is correct but these two notations are not exactly the same thing written twice.

Inside the braces of the class (in the .h file) this is a declaration.
It is a kind of promise saying "I swear this exists somewhere".
This can be seen in many translation units (i.e. .cpp files including this .h file).

On the other hand, what you wrote in your .cpp file is the definition of this variable; it must exist exactly once in your program.

An alternative exists since C++17: inline variables.
It offers the ability to skip the definition of the static variable in the .cpp file (useful for header-only solutions).

How properly instantiate static field tat is another class object

1 Answers1