Efficient way to remove ALL whitespace from String?

Question

I'm calling a REST API and am receiving an XML response back. It returns a list of a workspace names, and I'm writing a quick IsExistingWorkspace() method. Since all workspaces consist of contiguous characters with no whitespace, I'm assuming the easiest way to find out if a particular workspace is in the list is to remove all whitespace (including newlines) and doing this (XML is the string received from the web request):

XML.Contains("<name>" + workspaceName + "</name>");

I know it's case-sensitive, and I'm relying on that. I just need a way to remove all whitespace in a string efficiently. I know RegEx and LINQ can do it, but I'm open to other ideas. I am mostly just concerned about speed.

Answer 1

This is fastest way I know of, even though you said you didn't want to use regular expressions:

Regex.Replace(XML, @"\s+", "");

Crediting @hypehuman in the comments, if you plan to do this more than once, create and store a Regex instance. This will save the overhead of constructing it every time, which is more expensive than you might think.

private static readonly Regex sWhitespace = new Regex(@"\s+");
public static string ReplaceWhitespace(string input, string replacement) 
{
    return sWhitespace.Replace(input, replacement);
}

Answer 2

I have an alternative way without regexp, and it seems to perform pretty good. It is a continuation on Brandon Moretz answer:

 public static string RemoveWhitespace(this string input)
 {
    return new string(input.ToCharArray()
        .Where(c => !Char.IsWhiteSpace(c))
        .ToArray());
 }

I tested it in a simple unit test:

[Test]
[TestCase("123 123 1adc \n 222", "1231231adc222")]
public void RemoveWhiteSpace1(string input, string expected)
{
    string s = null;
    for (int i = 0; i < 1000000; i++)
    {
        s = input.RemoveWhitespace();
    }
    Assert.AreEqual(expected, s);
}

[Test]
[TestCase("123 123 1adc \n 222", "1231231adc222")]
public void RemoveWhiteSpace2(string input, string expected)
{
    string s = null;
    for (int i = 0; i < 1000000; i++)
    {
        s = Regex.Replace(input, @"\s+", "");
    }
    Assert.AreEqual(expected, s);
}

For 1,000,000 attempts the first option (without regexp) runs in less than a second (700 ms on my machine), and the second takes 3.5 seconds.

Answer 3

Try the replace method of the string in C#.

XML.Replace(" ", string.Empty);

Answer 4

My solution is to use Split and Join and it is surprisingly fast, in fact the fastest of the top answers here.

str = string.Join("", str.Split(default(string[]), StringSplitOptions.RemoveEmptyEntries));

Timings for 10,000 loop on simple string with whitespace inc new lines and tabs

• split/join = 60 milliseconds
• linq chararray = 94 milliseconds
• regex = 437 milliseconds

Improve this by wrapping it up in method to give it meaning, and also make it an extension method while we are at it ...

public static string RemoveWhitespace(this string str) {
    return string.Join("", str.Split(default(string[]), StringSplitOptions.RemoveEmptyEntries));
}

Answer 5

Building on Henks answer I have created some test methods with his answer and some added, more optimized, methods. I found the results differ based on the size of the input string. Therefore, I have tested with two result sets. In the fastest method, the linked source has a even faster way. But, since it is characterized as unsafe I have left this out.

Long input string results:

1. InPlaceCharArray: 2021 ms (Sunsetquest's answer) - (Original source)
2. String split then join: 4277ms (Kernowcode's answer)
3. String reader: 6082 ms
4. LINQ using native char.IsWhitespace: 7357 ms
5. LINQ: 7746 ms (Henk's answer)
6. ForLoop: 32320 ms
7. RegexCompiled: 37157 ms
8. Regex: 42940 ms

Short input string results:

1. InPlaceCharArray: 108 ms (Sunsetquest's answer) - (Original source)
2. String split then join: 294 ms (Kernowcode's answer)
3. String reader: 327 ms
4. ForLoop: 343 ms
5. LINQ using native char.IsWhitespace: 624 ms
6. LINQ: 645ms (Henk's answer)
7. RegexCompiled: 1671 ms
8. Regex: 2599 ms

Code:

public class RemoveWhitespace
{
    public static string RemoveStringReader(string input)
    {
        var s = new StringBuilder(input.Length); // (input.Length);
        using (var reader = new StringReader(input))
        {
            int i = 0;
            char c;
            for (; i < input.Length; i++)
            {
                c = (char)reader.Read();
                if (!char.IsWhiteSpace(c))
                {
                    s.Append(c);
                }
            }
        }

        return s.ToString();
    }

    public static string RemoveLinqNativeCharIsWhitespace(string input)
    {
        return new string(input.ToCharArray()
            .Where(c => !char.IsWhiteSpace(c))
            .ToArray());
    }

    public static string RemoveLinq(string input)
    {
        return new string(input.ToCharArray()
            .Where(c => !Char.IsWhiteSpace(c))
            .ToArray());
    }

    public static string RemoveRegex(string input)
    {
        return Regex.Replace(input, @"\s+", "");
    }

    private static Regex compiled = new Regex(@"\s+", RegexOptions.Compiled);
    public static string RemoveRegexCompiled(string input)
    {
        return compiled.Replace(input, "");
    }

    public static string RemoveForLoop(string input)
    {
        for (int i = input.Length - 1; i >= 0; i--)
        {
            if (char.IsWhiteSpace(input[i]))
            {
                input = input.Remove(i, 1);
            }
        }
        return input;
    }

    public static string StringSplitThenJoin(this string str)
    {
        return string.Join("", str.Split(default(string[]), StringSplitOptions.RemoveEmptyEntries));
    }

    public static string RemoveInPlaceCharArray(string input)
    {
        var len = input.Length;
        var src = input.ToCharArray();
        int dstIdx = 0;
        for (int i = 0; i < len; i++)
        {
            var ch = src[i];
            switch (ch)
            {
                case '\u0020':
                case '\u00A0':
                case '\u1680':
                case '\u2000':
                case '\u2001':
                case '\u2002':
                case '\u2003':
                case '\u2004':
                case '\u2005':
                case '\u2006':
                case '\u2007':
                case '\u2008':
                case '\u2009':
                case '\u200A':
                case '\u202F':
                case '\u205F':
                case '\u3000':
                case '\u2028':
                case '\u2029':
                case '\u0009':
                case '\u000A':
                case '\u000B':
                case '\u000C':
                case '\u000D':
                case '\u0085':
                    continue;
                default:
                    src[dstIdx++] = ch;
                    break;
            }
        }
        return new string(src, 0, dstIdx);
    }
}

Tests:

[TestFixture]
public class Test
{
    // Short input
    //private const string input = "123 123 \t 1adc \n 222";
    //private const string expected = "1231231adc222";

    // Long input
    private const string input = "123 123 \t 1adc \n 222123 123 \t 1adc \n 222123 123 \t 1adc \n 222123 123 \t 1adc \n 222123 123 \t 1adc \n 222123 123 \t 1adc \n 222123 123 \t 1adc \n 222123 123 \t 1adc \n 222123 123 \t 1adc \n 222123 123 \t 1adc \n 222123 123 \t 1adc \n 222123 123 \t 1adc \n 222123 123 \t 1adc \n 222123 123 \t 1adc \n 222123 123 \t 1adc \n 222123 123 \t 1adc \n 222123 123 \t 1adc \n 222123 123 \t 1adc \n 222123 123 \t 1adc \n 222123 123 \t 1adc \n 222123 123 \t 1adc \n 222123 123 \t 1adc \n 222";
    private const string expected = "1231231adc2221231231adc2221231231adc2221231231adc2221231231adc2221231231adc2221231231adc2221231231adc2221231231adc2221231231adc2221231231adc2221231231adc2221231231adc2221231231adc2221231231adc2221231231adc2221231231adc2221231231adc2221231231adc2221231231adc2221231231adc2221231231adc222";

    private const int iterations = 1000000;

    [Test]
    public void RemoveInPlaceCharArray()
    {
        string s = null;
        var stopwatch = Stopwatch.StartNew();
        for (int i = 0; i < iterations; i++)
        {
            s = RemoveWhitespace.RemoveInPlaceCharArray(input);
        }

        stopwatch.Stop();
        Console.WriteLine("InPlaceCharArray: " + stopwatch.ElapsedMilliseconds + " ms");
        Assert.AreEqual(expected, s);
    }

    [Test]
    public void RemoveStringReader()
    {
        string s = null;
        var stopwatch = Stopwatch.StartNew();
        for (int i = 0; i < iterations; i++)
        {
            s = RemoveWhitespace.RemoveStringReader(input);
        }

        stopwatch.Stop();
        Console.WriteLine("String reader: " + stopwatch.ElapsedMilliseconds + " ms");
        Assert.AreEqual(expected, s);
    }

    [Test]
    public void RemoveLinqNativeCharIsWhitespace()
    {
        string s = null;
        var stopwatch = Stopwatch.StartNew();
        for (int i = 0; i < iterations; i++)
        {
            s = RemoveWhitespace.RemoveLinqNativeCharIsWhitespace(input);
        }

        stopwatch.Stop();
        Console.WriteLine("LINQ using native char.IsWhitespace: " + stopwatch.ElapsedMilliseconds + " ms");
        Assert.AreEqual(expected, s);
    }

    [Test]
    public void RemoveLinq()
    {
        string s = null;
        var stopwatch = Stopwatch.StartNew();
        for (int i = 0; i < iterations; i++)
        {
            s = RemoveWhitespace.RemoveLinq(input);
        }

        stopwatch.Stop();
        Console.WriteLine("LINQ: " + stopwatch.ElapsedMilliseconds + " ms");
        Assert.AreEqual(expected, s);
    }

    [Test]
    public void RemoveRegex()
    {
        string s = null;
        var stopwatch = Stopwatch.StartNew();
        for (int i = 0; i < iterations; i++)
        {
            s = RemoveWhitespace.RemoveRegex(input);
        }

        stopwatch.Stop();
        Console.WriteLine("Regex: " + stopwatch.ElapsedMilliseconds + " ms");

        Assert.AreEqual(expected, s);
    }

    [Test]
    public void RemoveRegexCompiled()
    {
        string s = null;
        var stopwatch = Stopwatch.StartNew();
        for (int i = 0; i < iterations; i++)
        {
            s = RemoveWhitespace.RemoveRegexCompiled(input);
        }

        stopwatch.Stop();
        Console.WriteLine("RegexCompiled: " + stopwatch.ElapsedMilliseconds + " ms");

        Assert.AreEqual(expected, s);
    }

    [Test]
    public void RemoveForLoop()
    {
        string s = null;
        var stopwatch = Stopwatch.StartNew();
        for (int i = 0; i < iterations; i++)
        {
            s = RemoveWhitespace.RemoveForLoop(input);
        }

        stopwatch.Stop();
        Console.WriteLine("ForLoop: " + stopwatch.ElapsedMilliseconds + " ms");

        Assert.AreEqual(expected, s);
    }

    [TestMethod]
    public void StringSplitThenJoin()
    {
        string s = null;
        var stopwatch = Stopwatch.StartNew();
        for (int i = 0; i < iterations; i++)
        {
            s = RemoveWhitespace.StringSplitThenJoin(input);
        }

        stopwatch.Stop();
        Console.WriteLine("StringSplitThenJoin: " + stopwatch.ElapsedMilliseconds + " ms");

        Assert.AreEqual(expected, s);
    }
}

Edit: Tested a nice one liner from Kernowcode.

Answer 6

Just an alternative because it looks quite nice :) - NOTE: Henks answer is the quickest of these.

input.ToCharArray()
 .Where(c => !Char.IsWhiteSpace(c))
 .Select(c => c.ToString())
 .Aggregate((a, b) => a + b);

Testing 1,000,000 loops on "This is a simple Test"

This method = 1.74 seconds
Regex = 2.58 seconds
new String (Henks) = 0.82 seconds

Answer 7

I found a nice write-up on this on CodeProject by Felipe Machado (with help by Richard Robertson)

He tested ten different methods. This one is the fastest safe version...

public static string TrimAllWithInplaceCharArray(string str) {

    var len = str.Length;
    var src = str.ToCharArray();
    int dstIdx = 0;

    for (int i = 0; i < len; i++) {
        var ch = src[i];

        switch (ch) {

            case '\u0020': case '\u00A0': case '\u1680': case '\u2000': case '\u2001':

            case '\u2002': case '\u2003': case '\u2004': case '\u2005': case '\u2006':

            case '\u2007': case '\u2008': case '\u2009': case '\u200A': case '\u202F':

            case '\u205F': case '\u3000': case '\u2028': case '\u2029': case '\u0009':

            case '\u000A': case '\u000B': case '\u000C': case '\u000D': case '\u0085':
                continue;

            default:
                src[dstIdx++] = ch;
                break;
        }
    }
    return new string(src, 0, dstIdx);
}

And the fastest unsafe version... (some inprovements by Sunsetquest 5/26/2021 )

public static unsafe void RemoveAllWhitespace(ref string str)
{
    fixed (char* pfixed = str)
    {
        char* dst = pfixed;
        for (char* p = pfixed; *p != 0; p++)
        {
            switch (*p)
            {
                case '\u0020': case '\u00A0': case '\u1680': case '\u2000': case '\u2001':
                case '\u2002': case '\u2003': case '\u2004': case '\u2005': case '\u2006':
                case '\u2007': case '\u2008': case '\u2009': case '\u200A': case '\u202F':
                case '\u205F': case '\u3000': case '\u2028': case '\u2029': case '\u0009':
                case '\u000A': case '\u000B': case '\u000C': case '\u000D': case '\u0085':
                continue;

                default:
                    *dst++ = *p;
                    break;
            }
        }

        uint* pi = (uint*)pfixed;
        ulong len = ((ulong)dst - (ulong)pfixed) >> 1;
        pi[-1] = (uint)len;
        pfixed[len] = '\0';
    }
}

There are also some nice independent benchmarks on Stack Overflow by Stian Standahl that also show how Felipe's function is about 300% faster than the next fastest function. Also, for the one I modified, I used this trick.

Answer 8

If you need superb performance, you should avoid LINQ and regular expressions in this case. I did some performance benchmarking, and it seems that if you want to strip white space from beginning and end of the string, string.Trim() is your ultimate function.

If you need to strip all white spaces from a string, the following method works fastest of all that has been posted here:

    public static string RemoveWhitespace(this string input)
    {
        int j = 0, inputlen = input.Length;
        char[] newarr = new char[inputlen];

        for (int i = 0; i < inputlen; ++i)
        {
            char tmp = input[i];

            if (!char.IsWhiteSpace(tmp))
            {
                newarr[j] = tmp;
                ++j;
            }
        }
        return new String(newarr, 0, j);
    }

Answer 9

Regex is overkill; just use extension on string (thanks Henk). This is trivial and should have been part of the framework. Anyhow, here's my implementation:

public static partial class Extension
{
    public static string RemoveWhiteSpace(this string self)
    {
        return new string(self.Where(c => !Char.IsWhiteSpace(c)).ToArray());
    }
}

Answer 10

I think alot of persons come here for removing spaces. :

string s = "my string is nice";
s = s.replace(" ", "");

Answer 11

I needed to replace white space in a string with spaces, but not duplicate spaces. e.g., I needed to convert something like the following:

"a b   c\r\n d\t\t\t e"

to

"a b c d e"

I used the following method

private static string RemoveWhiteSpace(string value)
{
    if (value == null) { return null; }
    var sb = new StringBuilder();

    var lastCharWs = false;
    foreach (var c in value)
    {
        if (char.IsWhiteSpace(c))
        {
            if (lastCharWs) { continue; }
            sb.Append(' ');
            lastCharWs = true;
        }
        else
        {
            sb.Append(c);
            lastCharWs = false;
        }
    }
    return sb.ToString();
}

Answer 12

Here is a simple linear alternative to the RegEx solution. I am not sure which is faster; you'd have to benchmark it.

static string RemoveWhitespace(string input)
{
    StringBuilder output = new StringBuilder(input.Length);

    for (int index = 0; index < input.Length; index++)
    {
        if (!Char.IsWhiteSpace(input, index))
        {
            output.Append(input[index]);
        }
    }
    return output.ToString();
}

Answer 13

We can use:

    public static string RemoveWhitespace(this string input)
    {
        if (input == null)
            return null;
        return new string(input.ToCharArray()
            .Where(c => !Char.IsWhiteSpace(c))
            .ToArray());
    }

Answer 14

I assume your XML response looks like this:

var xml = @"<names>
                <name>
                    foo
                </name>
                <name>
                    bar
                </name>
            </names>";

The best way to process XML is to use an XML parser, such as LINQ to XML:

var doc = XDocument.Parse(xml);

var containsFoo = doc.Root
                     .Elements("name")
                     .Any(e => ((string)e).Trim() == "foo");

Answer 15

Using Linq, you can write a readable method this way :

    public static string RemoveAllWhitespaces(this string source)
    {
        return string.IsNullOrEmpty(source) ? source : new string(source.Where(x => !char.IsWhiteSpace(x)).ToArray());
    }

Answer 16

Here is yet another variant:

public static string RemoveAllWhitespace(string aString)
{
  return String.Join(String.Empty, aString.Where(aChar => aChar !Char.IsWhiteSpace(aChar)));
}

As with most of the other solutions, I haven't performed exhaustive benchmark tests, but this works well enough for my purposes.

Answer 17

The straightforward way to remove all whitespaces from a string, "example" is your initial string.

String.Concat(example.Where(c => !Char.IsWhiteSpace(c))

Answer 18

I have found different results to be true. I am trying to replace all whitespace with a single space and the regex was extremely slow.

return( Regex::Replace( text, L"\s+", L" " ) );

What worked the most optimally for me (in C++ cli) was:

String^ ReduceWhitespace( String^ text )
{
  String^ newText;
  bool    inWhitespace = false;
  Int32   posStart = 0;
  Int32   pos      = 0;
  for( pos = 0; pos < text->Length; ++pos )
  {
    wchar_t cc = text[pos];
    if( Char::IsWhiteSpace( cc ) )
    {
      if( !inWhitespace )
      {
        if( pos > posStart ) newText += text->Substring( posStart, pos - posStart );
        inWhitespace = true;
        newText += L' ';
      }
      posStart = pos + 1;
    }
    else
    {
      if( inWhitespace )
      {
        inWhitespace = false;
        posStart = pos;
      }
    }
  }

  if( pos > posStart ) newText += text->Substring( posStart, pos - posStart );

  return( newText );
}

I tried the above routine first by replacing each character separately, but had to switch to doing substrings for the non-space sections. When applying to a 1,200,000 character string:

• the above routine gets it done in 25 seconds
• the above routine + separate character replacement in 95 seconds
• the regex aborted after 15 minutes.

Answer 19

It's arguably not as expressive as using Regex or using Char.IsWhiteSpace, but the following is by far the most concise version of this:

public static string RemoveWhitespace(this string input)
{
   return string.Concat(input.Split(null));
}

This leverages the Split(Char[]) overload of Split(), which accepts null for its only parameter, and interprets that value as "split on all whitespace" (the same outcome as if you used an empty char array or default(char[]) instead).

Internally, it uses Char.IsWhiteSpace to make the determination of whether it should split on a given character:

If the separator argument is null or contains no characters, the method treats white-space characters as the delimiters. White-space characters are defined by the Unicode standard, and the Char.IsWhiteSpace method returns true if a white-space character is passed to it.