How to fix the slow checkpoint with small state size issue?

Question

I have a flink app (flink version is 1.9.2) which enabled checkpoint function. When I run it in the apache flink platform. I always get the checkpoint failed message: Checkpoint expired before completing.After check the threadDumps of the taskManager during a checkpoint, I found that a thread which contains two operators that request external service was always in runnable state. Below are my design of this operator and the checkpoint configuration. Please help advise how to resolve the issue ?

operator design:

public class OperatorA extends RichMapFunction<POJOA, POJOA> {
    private Connection connection;
    private String getCusipSourceIdPairsQuery;
    private String getCusipListQuery;
    private MapState<String, List<POJOX>> modifiedCusipState;
    private MapState<String, List<POJOX>> bwicMatchedModifiedCusipState;
    
    @Override
    public POJOA map(POJOA value) throw Exception {
        // create local variable PreparedStatement every time invoke this map method
        // update/clear those two MapStates
    }
    
    @Override
    public void open(Configuration parameters) {
        // initialize jdbc connection and TTL MapStates using GlobalJobParameters
    }

    @Override
    public void close() {
        // close jdbc connection
    }
}

public class OperatorB extends RichMapFunction<POJOA, POJOA> {
    private MyServiceA serviceA;
    private MyServiceB serviceB;

    @Override
    public POJOA map(POJOA value) throw Exception {
        // call a restful GET API of ServiceB, get a XML response, about 500 fields in the response.
        // use serviceA's function to extract the XML document and then populate the value fields.
    }
    
    @Override
    public void open(Configuration parameters) {
        // initialize local jdbc connection and PreparedStatement using globalJobParameters. then use the executed results to initialize serviceA.
        // initialize serviceB.
    }
}

checkpoint configuration:

Checkpointing Mode                  Exactly Once
Interval                            15m 0s
Timeout                             10m 0s
Minimum Pause Between Checkpoints   5m 0s
Maximum Concurrent Checkpoints      1
Persist Checkpoints Externally      Disabled

Sample checkpoint history:

ID  Status          Acknowledged    Trigger Time    Latest Acknowledgement  End to End Duration     State Size  Buffered During Alignment   
20  In Progress     3/12 (25%)      15:03:13        15:04:14                1m 1s                   5.65 KB     0 B 
19  Failed          3/12            14:48:13        14:50:12                10m 0s                  5.65 KB     0 B 
18  Failed          3/12            14:33:13        14:34:50                10m 0s                  5.65 KB     0 B 
17  Failed          4/12            14:18:13        14:27:04                9m 59s                  2.91 MB     64.0 KB 
16  Failed          3/12            14:03:13        14:05:18                10m 0s                  5.65 KB     0 B

score 2 · Accepted Answer · answered Jul 03 '20 at 14:03

Doing any sort of blocking i/o in a Flink user function (e.g., a RichMap or ProcessFunction) is asking for trouble with checkpointing. The reason is that it is very easy to end up with significant backpressure, which then prevents the checkpoint barriers from making sufficiently rapid progress through the execution graph, leading to checkpoint timeouts.

The preferred way to improve on this would be to use async i/o rather than a RichMap. This will allow for there to be more outstanding requests at any given moment (assuming the external service is capable of handling the higher load), and won't leave the operator blocked in user code waiting for responses to synchronous requests -- thereby allowing checkpoints to progress unimpeded.

An alternative would be to increase the parallelism of your cluster, which should reduce the backpressure, but at the expense of tying up more computing resources that won't really doing much other than waiting.

In the worst case, where the external service simply isn't capable of keeping up with your throughput requirements, then backpressure is unavoidable. This then is going to be more difficult to manage, but unaligned checkpoints, coming in Flink 1.11, should help.

hi David. that's my actual case!. After refactoring the operatorB, the checkpoint can be completed in time. Thanks ~ — AlvinYueChao, Jul 05 '20 at 02:28
What a small world, David. I'm working in citi. I just completed your flink training two months ago! — AlvinYueChao, Jul 05 '20 at 02:31

score 1 · Answer 2 · answered Jul 03 '20 at 08:34

Here are some tips that I usually use during locating expired checkpoint problem:

Check Checkpoint UI to know the distribution of subtasks which cause the expiration.
If most subtasks already finish the checkpoint, skip to Tip 3, otherwise skip to Tip 4.
The most possible reason is data skew and the problem subtask receives much more records than other subtasks. If it's not a data skew problem, take a look at the host that the subtask is running on, and check whether there're issue about CPU/MEM/DISK which may slow down the consuming of the subtask.
This situation is relatively rare, and it's usually caused by used codes. For example, user tries to access database in operators but the connection is not stable which slows down the processing.

score 1 · Answer 3 · answered Jan 28 '21 at 23:54

I recently encountered a similar problem. Suggestions provided by @David Anderson are really good! Nevertheless, I have a few things to add.

You can try to tune your checkpoints according to Apache Flink documentation.

In my case, checkpoint interval was lower than min pause between checkpoints, so I increased it to make it bigger. In my case, I multiplied checkpoint interval by 2 and set this value as min pause between checkpoints.

You can also try to increase checkpoint timeout.

Another issue may be ValueState. My pipleline was keeping state for a long period of time and it wasn't evicted what was causing thoroughput problems. I set TTL for the ValueState (in my case for 30 minutes) and it started to work better. TTL is well described in the Apache Flink documentation. It's really simple and looks like that:

StateTtlConfig ttlConfig = StateTtlConfig
    .newBuilder(Time.seconds(1))
    .setUpdateType(StateTtlConfig.UpdateType.OnCreateAndWrite)
    .setStateVisibility(StateTtlConfig.StateVisibility.NeverReturnExpired)
    .build();
    
ValueStateDescriptor<String> stateDescriptor = new ValueStateDescriptor<>("text state", String.class);
stateDescriptor.enableTimeToLive(ttlConfig);

It's also worth noticing that this SO thread is related to the similar topic: Flink Checkpoint Failure - Checkpoints time out after 10 mins and tips provided there may be useful.

Regards,

Piotr

How to fix the slow checkpoint with small state size issue?

3 Answers3